Marks Ariel, Takahashi Courtney, Anand Pria, Lau K H Vincent
Department of Neurology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston Medical Center, Boston, MA.
Neurol Clin Pract. 2022 Jun;12(3):218-222. doi: 10.1212/CPJ.0000000000001163.
Medical errors are estimated to cause 7,000 deaths and cost 17-29 billion USD per year, but there is a lack of published real-world data on preventable errors, in particular in hospital-based neurology. We sought to characterize the profile of errors that occur on the inpatient neurology services at our institution to inform strategies on future error prevention.
We reviewed all cases of preventable errors occurring on the inpatient neurology services from July 1, 2018, to June 30, 2020, logged in institutional error reporting systems and reviewed at departmental morbidity and mortality conferences (M&MC). Each case was characterized by primary category of error, level of harm as determined by the Agency for Healthcare Research & Quality Common Format Harm Scale version 1.2, primary intervention, and recurrence within 1 year, with a final censoring date of June 30, 2021.
Of 72 cases, 43 (60%) were attributed to errors in clinical decision making and 20 (28%) to systems or electronic health record-related errors. The majority of cases resulted in in-conference education on systems-based errors (29%) at departmental M&MCs followed by in-conference education on clinical neurology (25%). Among errors classified primarily as clinical, 28% were addressed via systems-based interventions including in-conference education on systems issues and changes in written protocol. In 23 cases (32%), a similar error recurred within 1 year of the presentation. In total, 7 cases (10%) resulted in a change in written protocol, none with recurrences.
Systems-based interventions may reduce both clinical and systems-based errors, and protocol changes are effective when feasible. Given the important goal of optimizing care for every patient, quality leaders should conduct continuous audits of preventable errors and quality improvement systems in their clinical areas.
据估计,医疗差错每年导致7000人死亡,造成170亿至290亿美元的损失,但缺乏已发表的关于可预防差错的真实世界数据,尤其是在医院神经内科领域。我们试图描述我院住院神经内科服务中发生的差错特征,为未来的差错预防策略提供依据。
我们回顾了2018年7月1日至2020年6月30日期间住院神经内科服务中发生的所有可预防差错病例,这些病例记录在机构差错报告系统中,并在科室发病率和死亡率会议(M&MC)上进行了审查。每个病例的特征包括差错的主要类别、根据医疗保健研究与质量局通用格式伤害量表1.2版确定的伤害程度、主要干预措施以及1年内的复发情况,最终审查日期为2021年6月30日。
在72例病例中,43例(60%)归因于临床决策失误,20例(28%)归因于系统或电子健康记录相关差错。大多数病例在科室M&MC会议上导致了关于基于系统差错的会议内教育(29%),其次是关于临床神经病学的会议内教育(25%)。在主要归类为临床的差错中,28%通过基于系统的干预措施得到解决,包括关于系统问题的会议内教育和书面协议的更改。在23例(32%)病例中,类似差错在报告后1年内复发。总共7例(10%)导致书面协议更改,无一例复发。
基于系统的干预措施可能会减少临床和基于系统的差错,并且在可行时协议更改是有效的。鉴于优化每位患者护理的重要目标,质量负责人应在其临床领域对可预防差错和质量改进系统进行持续审核。