Vogel S B, Wolfe M M, McGuigan J E, Hawkins I F, Howard R J, Woodward E R
Ann Surg. 1987 May;205(5):550-6. doi: 10.1097/00000658-198705000-00014.
From 1971-1986, 24 patients were diagnosed as having Zollinger-Ellison syndrome (ZES) and 22 patients had laparotomy. Of this group, gross tumor was identified in 15 of 22 patients. Ten of 15 patients had resection of their gastrinomas with the specific aim of curing the disease. This group had responded favorably to either cimetidine or ranitidine before operation. Preoperative transhepatic portal venous sampling (PVS) with gastrin determinations was performed in six patients; three patients had this procedure twice. The tumor was correctly localized by PVS in five of six patients. In four of six patients, the tumor was easily found at surgery. In two of six patients (33%) PVS was vital to intraoperative decisions. Criteria for biochemical cure are normal periodic fasting gastrin and secretin infusion tests. Of the 10 patients who had resection for potential cure, two patients failed within 48 hours of surgery on the basis of an elevated fasting serum gastrin level in one patient and a positive secretin infusion test in the other patient. Eight patients were considered cured with follow-up from 6 months through 15 years. Of the eight cured patients, the tumors were located as follows: four were extraintestinal and extrapancreatic, four were in the duodenal wall, one patient had a tumor located in the uncinate process of the pancreas, and one tumor was located in a lymph node along the lesser curve of the stomach. Two patients had mobilization of the pancreas and duodenum for a "blind" pancreatoduodenectomy based on preoperative PVS (2 procedures each patient). In one patient a 3-mm gastrinoma was enucleated from the posterior uncinate process. The second patient had pancreatoduodenectomy with findings of two duodenal wall gastrinomas. Both patients remained cured of ZES beyond 2 years. It is concluded that PVS does indeed locate some tumors before operation, even those not easily found at surgery. ZES can be cured by an aggressive approach combining preoperative tumor localization and tumor resection. Of the eight patients biochemically and perhaps biologically cured, follow-up was greater than four years in five patients, greater than two years in two patients, and beyond six months in one patient.
1971年至1986年期间,24例患者被诊断为佐林格-埃利森综合征(ZES),其中22例患者接受了剖腹手术。在这组患者中,22例中有15例发现了肉眼可见的肿瘤。15例患者中有10例接受了胃泌素瘤切除术,目的是治愈该疾病。该组患者在手术前对西咪替丁或雷尼替丁反应良好。6例患者术前进行了经肝门静脉采血(PVS)并测定胃泌素;3例患者进行了两次该操作。6例患者中有5例通过PVS正确定位了肿瘤。6例患者中有4例在手术中很容易找到肿瘤。6例患者中有2例(33%)PVS对术中决策至关重要。生化治愈的标准是定期空腹胃泌素和促胰液素输注试验正常。在10例接受切除以寻求治愈的患者中,2例患者在手术后48小时内未治愈,其中1例患者空腹血清胃泌素水平升高,另1例患者促胰液素输注试验呈阳性。8例患者经6个月至15年的随访被认为已治愈。在8例治愈的患者中,肿瘤位置如下:4例位于肠外和胰外,4例位于十二指肠壁,1例患者的肿瘤位于胰腺钩突,1例肿瘤位于胃小弯处的淋巴结。2例患者基于术前PVS进行了胰腺和十二指肠游离以进行“盲目”胰十二指肠切除术(每位患者进行2次手术)。1例患者从胰腺钩突后部摘除了一个3毫米的胃泌素瘤。第二例患者进行了胰十二指肠切除术,发现了两个十二指肠壁胃泌素瘤。两名患者超过2年仍未复发ZES。结论是PVS确实能在手术前定位一些肿瘤,即使是那些在手术中不易发现的肿瘤。通过术前肿瘤定位和肿瘤切除相结合的积极方法可以治愈ZES。在8例生化治愈且可能生物学治愈的患者中,5例患者的随访时间超过4年,2例患者超过2年,1例患者超过6个月。