From the Department of Pediatrics, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, North Carolina.
Department of Pediatrics, Sanford Health, Bismarck, North Dakota.
J Patient Saf. 2022 Sep 1;18(6):e928-e933. doi: 10.1097/PTS.0000000000001049. Epub 2022 Jul 7.
Hospitals rely on voluntary event reporting (VER) for adverse event (AE) identification, although it captures fewer events than a trigger tool, such as Global Assessment of Pediatric Patient Safety (GAPPS). Medical providers exhibit bias based on patient weight status, race, and English proficiency. We compared the AE rate identified by VER with that identified using the GAPPS between hospitalized children by weight category, race, and English proficiency.
We identified a cohort of patients 2 years to younger than 18 years consecutively discharged from an academic children's hospital between June and October 2018. We collected data on patient weight status from age, sex, height, and weight, race/ethnicity by self-report, and limited English proficiency by record of interpreter use. We reviewed each chart with the GAPPS to identify AEs and reviewed VER entries for each encounter. We calculated an AE rate per 1000 patient-days using each method and compared these using analysis of variance.
We reviewed 834 encounters in 680 subjects; 262 (38.5%) had overweight or obesity, 144 (21.2%) identified as Black, and 112 (16.5%) identified as Hispanic; 82 (9.8%) of encounters involved an interpreter. We identified 288 total AEs, 270 (93.8%) by the GAPPS and 18 (6.3%) by VER. A disparity in AE reporting was found for children with limited English proficiency, with fewer AEs by VER ( P = 0.03) compared with no difference in AEs by GAPPS. No disparities were found by weight category or race.
Voluntary event reporting may systematically underreport AEs in hospitalized children with limited English proficiency.
医院依靠自愿事件报告(VER)来识别不良事件(AE),尽管它捕获的事件比触发工具(如儿科患者安全全球评估(GAPPS))少。医疗提供者会根据患者的体重状况、种族和英语水平表现出偏见。我们比较了通过体重类别、种族和英语水平住院儿童的 VER 和 GAPPS 识别的 AE 发生率。
我们连续确定了 2018 年 6 月至 10 月期间从一家学术儿童医院出院的年龄在 2 岁以下至 18 岁以下的患者队列。我们从年龄、性别、身高和体重收集患者体重状况的数据,通过自我报告收集种族/民族信息,通过使用口译员记录来收集英语水平有限的信息。我们使用 GAPPS 对每个图表进行审核以识别 AE,并审核每次就诊的 VER 记录。我们使用方差分析比较了每种方法计算的每 1000 患者天的 AE 率。
我们对 680 名患者的 834 次就诊进行了审查;262 名(38.5%)超重或肥胖,144 名(21.2%)为黑人,112 名(16.5%)为西班牙裔;82 次就诊涉及口译员。我们共发现 288 例总 AE,其中 270 例(93.8%)通过 GAPPS,18 例(6.3%)通过 VER。英语水平有限的患者 VER 报告的 AE 差异较大(P=0.03),而 GAPPS 中则没有差异。体重类别或种族均无差异。
自愿事件报告可能会系统地低估英语水平有限的住院儿童的 AE。