School of Public Health, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Adelaide, Level 4, Rundle Mall Plaza, 50 Rundle Mall, Adelaide 5000, Australia.
Australian Centre for Engagement, Evidence and Values, University of Wollongong, Northfields Ave, Wollongong 2522, Australia.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Jun 25;19(13):7817. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19137817.
Globally, there is an urgent need for solutions that can support our aging populations to live well and reduce the associated economic, social and health burdens. Implementing smart technologies within homes and communities may assist people to live well and 'age in place'. To date, there has been little consultation with older Australians addressing either the perceived benefits, or the potential social and ethical challenges associated with smart technology use. To address this, we conducted five World Cafés in two Australian states, aiming to capture citizen knowledge about the possibilities and challenges of smart technologies. The participants ( = 84) were aged 55 years and over, English-speaking, and living independently. Grounding our analysis in values-based social science and biomedical ethical principles, we identified the themes reflecting the participants' understanding, resistance, and acceptance of smart technologies, and the ethical principles, including beneficence, non-maleficence, autonomy, privacy, confidentiality, and justice. Similar to other studies, many of the participants demonstrated cautious and conditional acceptance of smart technologies, while identifying concerns about social isolation, breaches of privacy and confidentiality, surveillance, and stigmatization. Attention to understanding and incorporating the values of older citizens will be important for the acceptance and effectiveness of smart technologies for supporting independent and full lives for older citizens.
在全球范围内,我们迫切需要能够帮助老年人过上健康生活并减轻相关经济、社会和健康负担的解决方案。在家庭和社区中实施智能技术可能有助于人们过上健康的生活并“安享晚年”。迄今为止,对于智能技术的使用,无论是对其潜在的社会和伦理挑战的感知益处,还是对其感知益处,都很少与澳大利亚老年人进行协商。为了解决这个问题,我们在澳大利亚的两个州进行了五次世界咖啡馆活动,旨在收集公民对智能技术的可能性和挑战的了解。参与者(=84 人)年龄在 55 岁及以上,会说英语,并且独立生活。我们将基于价值的社会科学和生物医学伦理原则作为我们的分析基础,确定了反映参与者对智能技术的理解、抵制和接受程度的主题,以及包括善行、不伤害、自主性、隐私、机密性和正义在内的伦理原则。与其他研究类似,许多参与者对智能技术持谨慎和有条件的接受态度,同时也对社会隔离、侵犯隐私和机密性、监控以及污名化等问题表示担忧。关注理解和纳入老年公民的价值观对于智能技术的接受和有效性至关重要,因为这些技术有助于支持老年公民过上独立和充实的生活。