Morris Patricia, McCloskey Rose, Bulman Donna
School of Graduate Studies, University of New Brunswick, Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada.
Department of Nursing and Health Sciences, University of New Brunswick, Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada.
Innov Aging. 2022 Apr 21;6(4):igac028. doi: 10.1093/geroni/igac028. eCollection 2022.
This concept analysis aims to explore iatrogenesis within the context of residential dementia care and to distinguish this phenomenon from similar phenomena, such as abuse and inadvertent harm.
Walker and Avant's method for concept analysis was used to define critical attributes of iatrogenesis within residential dementia care, and to explore antecedents and consequences of its occurrence. A review of the literature about iatrogenesis in the context of residential dementia was conducted across 4 electronic databases. Texts about iatrogenesis in surgery, medicine, social work, psychology, and other relevant disciplines were also reviewed to provide additional context for the concept.
Iatrogenesis takes a unique form in residential dementia care. The final definition of the concept proposed in this article is habituated, forceful, hands-on care provided to residents who exhibit responsive behaviors that result in emotional, physical, spiritual, social harm, and/or gradual functional decline, that is provided with the intention of supporting the resident's safety and dignity.
The definition of iatrogenesis proposed in this article is an initial step toward developing evidence-based practice for the provision of nonconsensual assistance in residential dementia care. A theoretical definition like the one proposed in this article may serve as a starting point for the operationalization of the concept, which would promote future empirical research into staff and residents' experiences of health care-inflicted harms in this context. Theoretically, it contributes to critical conversations about the narratives, myths, and misperceptions that facilitate the provision of nonconsensual care.
本概念分析旨在探讨在痴呆症住院护理背景下的医源性疾病,并将这一现象与虐待和意外伤害等类似现象区分开来。
采用沃克和阿万特的概念分析方法来定义痴呆症住院护理中医源性疾病的关键属性,并探讨其发生的前因后果。通过4个电子数据库对有关痴呆症住院护理中医源性疾病的文献进行了综述。还查阅了外科、医学、社会工作、心理学及其他相关学科中关于医源性疾病的文献,以为该概念提供更多背景信息。
医源性疾病在痴呆症住院护理中呈现出独特的形式。本文提出的该概念的最终定义是:对表现出反应性行为的居民提供习惯性、强制性的亲身护理,这种护理会导致情感、身体、精神、社交方面的伤害和/或功能逐渐衰退,而提供这种护理的目的是维护居民的安全与尊严。
本文提出的医源性疾病定义是朝着为痴呆症住院护理中提供非自愿性协助制定循证实践迈出的第一步。像本文提出的这种理论定义可作为该概念操作化的起点,这将推动未来对医护造成伤害情况下工作人员和居民经历的实证研究。从理论上讲,它有助于就促成非自愿护理的叙述、神话和误解展开批判性讨论。