Marteau T M, Johnston M, Baum J D, Bloch S
J Behav Med. 1987 Feb;10(1):33-48. doi: 10.1007/BF00845126.
Treatment failure is usually understood as a problem of patient compliance. This paper suggests another approach: to see this problem as resulting from a difference in the goals of the two parties involved, the doctor and the patient. Comparison was made between the goals of doctors and those of parents in treating children with diabetes. Significant differences emerged between the goals. Parents' goals of treatment were governed more by avoidance of the short-term threat of diabetes (hypoglycemia); doctors' goals more by the long-term threat of diabetes (diabetic complications). The outcome of treatment (diabetic control) was more closely related to parents' than doctors' goals of control. These results indicate that doctors and patients do not always share the same goals in treatment. It is suggested that a more effective clinical alliance would result if the goals of the clinical team were at least made explicit, even if they were not always shared.
