Kirkwood Elizabeth K, Clymer Caitlin, Imbulana Kheminda, Mozumder Sumaya, Dibley Michael J, Alam Neeloy Ashraful
Sydney School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health, University of Sydney, Camperdown, Australia.
University of Sydney, Camperdown, Australia.
JMIR Hum Factors. 2022 Jul 21;9(3):e32330. doi: 10.2196/32330.
The rapid and widespread growth of mobile technologies in low- and middle-income countries can offer groundbreaking ways of disseminating public health interventions. However, gender-based inequalities present a challenge for women in accessing mobile technology. Research has shown that mobile health (mHealth) interventions can affect gender relations in both positive and negative ways; however, few mHealth programs use a gender-sensitive lens when designing, implementing, or analyzing programs.
This systematic review aims to identify and summarize the findings of qualitative research studies that explore the impact of mHealth interventions on gender relations as a result of participating in such initiatives in low- and middle-income countries.
We performed a systematic literature review to examine empirical evidence of changes in gender relations attributed to participation in an mHealth intervention in low- and middle-income countries. Peer-reviewed articles were included based on whether they evaluated an mHealth intervention and were published between 2013 and 2020. Articles using mHealth that solely targeted health workers, did not assess a specific intervention, used mobile technology for data collection only, or were formative or exploratory in nature were excluded. The search terms were entered into 4 key electronic databases-MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, and Scopus-generating a comprehensive list of potentially relevant peer-reviewed articles. Thematic analysis was used to identify, analyze, and report the themes that emerged from our data.
Of the 578 full-text articles retrieved, 14 (2.4%) were eligible for inclusion in the study. None of the articles appraised gender from the outset. The articles uncovered findings on gender relations through the course of the intervention or postprogram evaluation. Most studies took place in sub-Saharan Africa, with the remainder in South and Southeast Asia. The articles focused on maternal and child health, HIV diagnosis and treatment, and reproductive health. This review found that mHealth programs could enhance spousal communication, foster emotional support between couples, improve women's self-efficacy and autonomy in seeking health information and services, and increase their involvement in health-related decision-making. Despite the positive impacts, some mHealth interventions had an adverse effect, reinforcing the digital divide, upholding men as gatekeepers of information and sole decision-makers, and exacerbating relationship problems.
These results suggest that given the rapid and persistent upscale of mHealth interventions in low- and middle-income settings, it is imperative to design interventions that consider their impact on power dynamics and gender relations. Future research is needed to fill the evidence gaps on gender and mHealth, acknowledging that women are not passive beneficiaries and that they need to actively participate and be empowered by mHealth interventions.
移动技术在低收入和中等收入国家的迅速广泛普及,为公共卫生干预措施的传播提供了开创性的方式。然而,基于性别的不平等给女性获取移动技术带来了挑战。研究表明,移动健康(mHealth)干预措施对性别关系的影响有积极和消极两个方面;然而,很少有移动健康项目在设计、实施或分析项目时采用对性别问题有敏感认识的视角。
本系统评价旨在识别并总结定性研究的结果,这些研究探讨了在低收入和中等收入国家参与移动健康干预措施对性别关系的影响。
我们进行了一项系统的文献综述,以检验关于在低收入和中等收入国家参与移动健康干预措施所导致的性别关系变化的实证证据。纳入的同行评审文章需满足是否评估了移动健康干预措施且发表于2013年至2020年之间。仅针对卫生工作者、未评估特定干预措施、仅使用移动技术进行数据收集或本质上是形成性或探索性的使用移动健康的文章被排除。检索词被输入到4个关键电子数据库——MEDLINE、EMBASE、PsycINFO和Scopus——中,生成了一份潜在相关同行评审文章的综合列表。采用主题分析法来识别、分析和报告从我们的数据中浮现的主题。
在检索到的578篇全文文章中,有14篇(2.4%)符合纳入本研究的条件。没有一篇文章从一开始就评估性别问题。这些文章在干预过程或项目后评估中揭示了关于性别关系的发现。大多数研究在撒哈拉以南非洲进行,其余在南亚和东南亚。这些文章聚焦于孕产妇和儿童健康、艾滋病毒诊断与治疗以及生殖健康。本综述发现,移动健康项目可以加强配偶间的沟通,促进夫妻间的情感支持,提高女性在寻求健康信息和服务方面的自我效能感和自主权,并增加她们对与健康相关决策的参与度。尽管有这些积极影响,但一些移动健康干预措施也有不利影响,加剧了数字鸿沟,将男性视为信息的守门人和唯一决策者,并加剧了关系问题。
这些结果表明,鉴于移动健康干预措施在低收入和中等收入环境中迅速且持续的升级,设计考虑其对权力动态和性别关系影响的干预措施至关重要。需要未来的研究来填补关于性别与移动健康的证据空白,认识到女性不是被动的受益者,她们需要积极参与并通过移动健康干预措施获得赋权。