Newbury-Birch Dorothy, Ferguson Jennifer, Connor Natalie, Divers Andrew, Waller Gillian
School of Social Sciences, Humanities and Law, Teesside University, Middlesbrough, United Kingdom.
Front Psychiatry. 2022 Jul 7;13:900186. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.900186. eCollection 2022.
Although the relationship is complex, there is an association between alcohol use and offending behavior with an interplay between the amount drank, the pattern of drinking and individual and contextual factors. Alcohol brief interventions have been shown to be effective in primary healthcare, however there is currently a lack of compelling evidence in the criminal justice system. We carried out a rapid systematic review of the literature, which updated our review conducted in 2016. Following systematic searches, we included 36 papers on prevalence and 13 papers on effectiveness. Between 26 and 88% of individuals in the policy custody setting scored positive for an alcohol use disorder. In the magistrates court this was 95%; 31-86% in the probation setting and between 19 and 86% in the prison system. In relation to probable dependence, between 21 and 38% of individuals were shown to have probable alcohol dependence in the police custody suite setting; 39 per cent in the magistrate court system; 17-36% in the probation setting and between 18 and 48% in the prison system. This compares to 6% in the general population. We included 13 studies of effectiveness with differing outcome measures and outcomes. We conclude more studies are needed in the field to develop the current evidence base.
尽管这种关系很复杂,但饮酒与犯罪行为之间存在关联,饮酒量、饮酒模式以及个人和环境因素之间相互影响。酒精简短干预已被证明在初级医疗保健中有效,然而目前在刑事司法系统中缺乏令人信服的证据。我们对文献进行了快速系统综述,更新了我们在2016年进行的综述。经过系统检索,我们纳入了36篇关于患病率的论文和13篇关于有效性的论文。在警方拘留场所,26%至88%的人酒精使用障碍检测呈阳性。在地方法院,这一比例为95%;在缓刑环境中为31%至86%,在监狱系统中为19%至86%。关于可能的依赖情况,在警方拘留套房环境中,21%至38%的人被证明可能存在酒精依赖;在地方法院系统中为39%;在缓刑环境中为17%至36%,在监狱系统中为18%至48%。相比之下,普通人群中的这一比例为6%。我们纳入了13项关于有效性的研究,这些研究的结果测量和结果各不相同。我们得出结论,该领域需要更多研究来发展当前的证据基础。