Pathria M, Sartoris D J, Resnick D
Radiology. 1987 Jul;164(1):227-30. doi: 10.1148/radiology.164.1.3588910.
Sensitivity and specificity of lumbar spine radiography in the assessment of facet joint osteoarthritis were evaluated, with computed tomography (CT) as the standard. Two independent radiologists used a four-point scale to blindly grade facet joint osteoarthritis on oblique radiographs and transaxial CT scans obtained within an 8-month period in 50 consecutive patients with pain in the lower back. The L-3 to L-4, L-4 to L-5, and L-5 to S-1 facet joints were evaluated, and 68% appeared abnormal on CT scans, with 28% exhibiting moderate or severe disease. Interobserver agreement was high for conventional radiography (perfect agreement in 57% and agreement to within one grade in 39%) and still higher for CT (perfect in 63% and to within one grade in 35%). Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis indicated that oblique radiography was most accurate (55% sensitivity, 69% specificity) in distinguishing the presence from the absence of disease; in distinguishing absent or mild from moderate or severe disease, the specificity of oblique radiography was higher, at 94%, but its sensitivity was much lower, at 23%. Conventional radiography is a useful technique in screening for facet joint osteoarthritis but is insensitive compared with CT.
以计算机断层扫描(CT)为标准,评估腰椎X线摄影在小关节骨关节炎评估中的敏感性和特异性。两位独立的放射科医生使用四点量表,对50例连续的下背部疼痛患者在8个月内获得的斜位X线片和经轴位CT扫描上的小关节骨关节炎进行盲法分级。对L-3至L-4、L-4至L-5和L-5至S-1小关节进行了评估,CT扫描显示68%的关节异常,其中28%表现为中度或重度疾病。观察者间对传统X线摄影的一致性较高(57%完全一致,39%相差不超过一级),对CT的一致性更高(63%完全一致,35%相差不超过一级)。受试者操作特征曲线分析表明,斜位X线摄影在区分疾病有无方面最准确(敏感性55%,特异性69%);在区分无或轻度与中度或重度疾病时,斜位X线摄影的特异性较高,为94%,但其敏感性低得多,为23%。传统X线摄影是筛查小关节骨关节炎的一种有用技术,但与CT相比不敏感。