Hamann Cara J, Peek-Asa Corinne
University of Iowa College of Public Health, Department of Epidemiology, 145 N. Riverside Drive, S449 CPHB, Iowa City, IA, USA.
University of Iowa Injury Prevention Research Center, 200 Newton Rd, Iowa City, IA, USA.
J Transp Health. 2017 Mar;4:363-372. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2016.11.006.
Bicycling has become increasingly popular in the United States in recent years for both recreation and utilitarian purposes. Yet, attributes of the bicycle riding experience and riding differences between adults and children and males and females are not well documented. Most existing data on bicycling trip characteristics are based on self-reported interviews or surveys, which are prone to recall bias. The purpose of this exploratory study was to capture naturalistic bicycling data to examine trip characteristics and compare exposure classification accuracy between GPS and video data. We enrolled 10 children and 10 adults and captured their bicycling trips for one week each using PedalPortal, a GPS-enabled helmet camera data capture and coding system developed by the authors and a team of engineering students. Overall, 261 trips, 57 hours, and 670 miles of bicycling were captured. The video data allowed for correct classification of riding location (sidewalk, bicycle lane, street, etc.), an advantage over GPS data alone. Child trips were significantly shorter in both time and distance than adult trips (p<0.01). The majority of male trips were commutes (69.8% child, 60.5% adult), while female trips were more evenly distributed among commute, non-commute utilitarian, and recreation. Adults primarily chose paved streets with no bicycle facilities, but also sought out on-road bicycle facilities (bike lanes and shared lane markings). Children rode most frequently on sidewalks. Results from this study demonstrate that the addition of video data can improve classification of bicycling exposure and differences by age and gender that can help planners and engineers better understand bicyclist behavior variations and increase safety by selecting appropriate and targeted countermeasures.
近年来,骑自行车在美国越来越受欢迎,既用于休闲娱乐,也用于实用目的。然而,关于骑行体验的特点以及成人与儿童、男性与女性之间的骑行差异并没有充分的记录。现有的大多数关于自行车出行特征的数据都是基于自我报告的访谈或调查,这容易产生回忆偏差。这项探索性研究的目的是获取自然状态下的骑行数据,以检查出行特征,并比较全球定位系统(GPS)数据和视频数据在暴露分类准确性方面的差异。我们招募了10名儿童和10名成人,使用PedalPortal(作者和一组工程专业学生开发的一种带有GPS功能的头盔摄像头数据采集与编码系统)分别记录他们一周的骑行情况。总体而言,共记录了261次出行、57小时的骑行以及670英里的骑行路程。视频数据能够正确分类骑行位置(人行道、自行车道、街道等),这是仅靠GPS数据所没有的优势。儿童的出行在时间和距离上都明显短于成人出行(p<0.01)。大多数男性出行是通勤(儿童为69.8%,成人为60.5%),而女性出行在通勤、非通勤实用出行和休闲出行之间分布更为均匀。成年人主要选择没有自行车设施的铺装街道,但也会寻找道路上的自行车设施(自行车道和共享车道标记)。儿童最常骑行在人行道上。这项研究的结果表明,增加视频数据可以改善对骑行暴露情况的分类,以及按年龄和性别划分的差异,这有助于规划者和工程师更好地理解骑行者行为的变化,并通过选择合适且有针对性的对策来提高安全性。