Global Pediatric Medicine, St Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, Tennessee, USA
Unidad Nacional de Oncologia Pediatrica, Guatemala City, Guatemala.
BMJ Open. 2022 Aug 11;12(8):e057350. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-057350.
To examine treatment decision-making priorities and experiences among parents of children with cancer in Guatemala.
This study was conducted at Guatemala's National Pediatric Cancer Center in Guatemala City.
Spanish-speaking parents of paediatric patients (≤18 years of age) diagnosed with any form of cancer within the 8 weeks prior to study enrolment. The quantitative portion of this study included 100 parent participants; the qualitative component included 20 parents. Most participants were Catholic or Evangelical Spanish-speaking mothers.
Priorities and experiences of cancer treatment decision-making including decision-making role and experienced regret.
A range of paediatric ages and cancer diagnoses were included. Most Guatemalan parents surveyed (70%) made decisions about their child's cancer together and almost all (94%) without input from their community. Surveyed parents predominately preferred shared decision-making with their child's oncologist (76%), however 69% agreed it was best not to be provided with many options. Two-thirds of surveyed parents (65%) held their preferred role in decision-making, with fathers more likely to hold their preferred role than mothers (p=0.02). A small number of parents (11%) experienced heightened decisional regret, which did not correlate with socio-demographic characteristics or preferred decision-making role. Qualitative results supported quantitative findings, demonstrating a decision-making process that emphasised trust and honesty.
Guatemalan parents preferred to make decisions with their medical team and appreciated providers who were honest and inclusive, but directive about decisions. This study reinforces the importance of the provider-parent relationship and encourages clinicians in all settings to ask about and honour each parent's desired role in decision-making.
研究危地马拉儿童癌症患儿父母的治疗决策优先事项和经验。
本研究在危地马拉首都危地马拉城的国家儿科癌症中心进行。
西班牙语为母语的儿科患者(≤18 岁)的父母,这些患者在研究入组前的 8 周内被诊断出患有任何形式的癌症。本研究的定量部分包括 100 名父母参与者;定性部分包括 20 名父母。大多数参与者是天主教或福音派西班牙语裔母亲。
包括癌症治疗决策的优先事项和经验,包括决策角色和体验到的遗憾。
纳入了一系列儿科年龄和癌症诊断。大多数接受调查的危地马拉父母(70%)共同决定了他们孩子的癌症治疗方案,几乎所有父母(94%)都没有听取社区的意见。调查的父母主要倾向于与孩子的肿瘤医生共同决策(76%),但 69%的父母同意最好不要提供很多选择。三分之二的调查父母(65%)持他们在决策中的首选角色,父亲比母亲更有可能持他们的首选角色(p=0.02)。少数父母(11%)经历了更高的决策遗憾,这与社会人口特征或首选决策角色无关。定性结果支持定量结果,表明决策过程强调信任和诚实。
危地马拉父母更喜欢与他们的医疗团队一起做出决策,并欣赏诚实和包容的提供者,但在决策方面具有指导作用。这项研究强调了提供者-父母关系的重要性,并鼓励所有环境中的临床医生询问并尊重每个父母在决策中的理想角色。