Department of Sociology, University of Bucharest, Bucharest, 030167, Romania.
Interdisciplinary School of Doctoral Studies, University of Bucharest, Bucharest, 050107, Romania.
Public Health. 2022 Sep;210:114-122. doi: 10.1016/j.puhe.2022.06.027. Epub 2022 Jul 4.
We estimate patterns of covariation between COVID-19 and measles vaccination rates and a set of widely used indicators of human, social, and economic capital across 146 countries.
We conduct exploratory analyses of social patterns that uphold vaccination success for COVID-19 and measles.
We use publicly available data on COVID vaccination rates and other country-level indicators from Our World in Data, Human Development Report, Corruption Perception Index, and the World Bank to devise bivariate correlations and multiple regression models.
About 70% of the variability in COVID-19 vaccination rates in February 2022 can be explained by differences in the Human Development Index (HDI) and, specifically, in life expectancy at birth. Trust in doctors and nurses adds predictive value beyond HDI, clarifying controversial discrepancies between vaccination rates in countries with similar levels of HDI and vaccine availability. Cardiovascular disease deaths, an indicator of general health system effectiveness, and infant measles immunization coverage, an indicator of country-level immunization effectiveness, are also significant, though weaker, predictors of COVID-19 vaccination success. Measles vaccination in 2019 is similarly predicted by HDI and trust in doctors and nurses.
The remaining variability in COVID-19 vaccination success that cannot be pinned down through these sets of metrics points to a considerable scope for collective and individual agency in a time of crisis. The mobilization and coordination in the vaccination campaigns of citizens, medical professionals, scientists, journalists, and politicians, among others, account for at least some of this variability in overcoming vaccine hesitancy and inequity.
我们估计了 COVID-19 和麻疹疫苗接种率与一组广泛用于衡量人类、社会和经济资本的指标之间的变化模式,涵盖了 146 个国家。
我们对支持 COVID-19 和麻疹疫苗接种成功的社会模式进行了探索性分析。
我们使用了来自 Our World in Data、人类发展报告、腐败感知指数和世界银行的公开数据,包括 COVID 疫苗接种率和其他国家层面的指标,以设计双变量相关性和多元回归模型。
2022 年 2 月 COVID-19 疫苗接种率的约 70%可以用人类发展指数(HDI)的差异来解释,特别是用出生时的预期寿命来解释。对医生和护士的信任增加了除 HDI 之外的预测价值,澄清了在具有相似 HDI 水平和疫苗可及性的国家之间疫苗接种率存在争议的差异。心血管疾病死亡率,这是一般卫生系统有效性的指标,以及 2019 年的婴儿麻疹免疫覆盖率,这是国家层面免疫有效性的指标,也是 COVID-19 疫苗接种成功的重要预测因素,但强度较弱。
通过这些指标无法确定的 COVID-19 疫苗接种成功的剩余可变性表明,在危机时期,集体和个人行动的范围相当大。公民、医疗专业人员、科学家、记者和政治家等在疫苗接种运动中的动员和协调至少在一定程度上解释了克服疫苗犹豫和不平等的这种可变性。