Burinskiene Aurelija
Department of Business Technology and Entrepreneurship, Business Management Faculty, Vilnius Gediminas Technical University, Vilnius, Lithuania.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2022 Aug 3;9:582186. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2022.582186. eCollection 2022.
Many forecasting methods are used to predict sales, such as the moving average method, naive method, exponential smoothing methods, Holt's linear method, and others. The results brought by these models are quite different. Forecast delivered by the naive method is entirely accurate for an extended period, like 3-5 years, Holt's methods are bringing accurate one-year period forecasts. The planning decisions have several levels, meaning different forecasting results. However, the authors that are testing various forecasting methods are not discussing results researched in different planning levels (retail chain and different pharmacies). The study is given to the construction of the forecasting model covering both planning levels, which later is empirically tested for the Lithuania retail case.
The development of the forecasting model for reduction of shortages in drug supply. To achieve this goal, the author revises the improvement of drug availability weekly.
The construction of the forecasting model is incorporating outliers' detection methods and sales by pharmacies to minimize shortage. In the forecasting model, the author uses Theil's U test to evaluate forecasting accuracy.
During analysis, the author constructs the model application for forecasting drug sales where weekly availability is highly recommended. The results show that forecasting on individual pharmacies level using the integration of these plans approach leads to higher accuracy.
The research covers 3 months of sales data. Das and Chaudhury suggest for short-sales period products use 36 days' time horizon. Ayati et al. discuss short and long-term time horizons for planning sales of drugs. Kanyalkar and Adil analyzed multi-site production and suggest that the time horizon should cover the longest lead time required for delivery of raw material, which is 12 weeks, and select 3 months (i.e., 13 weeks) as short-term time period horizon. Wongsunopparat and Chaveesuk forecast drug sales for 1-month and 12-month periods and compare the results. In this study, the focus is on short-term time-horizon, which is considered as 3 months period and also represents the longest lead-time. In the future, the study could review other periods. The author has incorporated the review of eight forecasting methods into the study by leaving other forecasting methods unresearched. Future studies could also incorporate different ARIMA methods into shortage reduction case analysis.
Presented forecasting model could be useful for practitioners, which analyze the reduction of the shortage of prescribed drugs. There the revision of repeated purchases is recommended for national authorities, wholesalers, and pharmacies aiming to minimize shortage.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: The analysis to reach the highest forecast accuracy and identification of a forecasting approach which responds to the fluctuation of weekly sales for the whole pharmacy chain and separate pharmacies. The study contributes to drug sales review, where most authors analyze the total volume, which is not separated by pharmacies.
许多预测方法被用于预测销售额,如移动平均法、朴素法、指数平滑法、霍尔特线性法等。这些模型带来的结果差异很大。朴素法得出的预测在较长时期(如3 - 5年)内完全准确,霍尔特法能得出准确的一年期预测。规划决策有多个层次,这意味着会有不同的预测结果。然而,测试各种预测方法的作者并未讨论在不同规划层次(零售连锁店和不同药店)上的研究结果。本研究致力于构建一个涵盖两个规划层次的预测模型,并随后针对立陶宛零售案例进行实证检验。
开发用于减少药品供应短缺的预测模型。为实现这一目标,作者每周对药品可及性的改善情况进行修订。
预测模型的构建纳入了异常值检测方法和药店销售额,以尽量减少短缺。在预测模型中,作者使用泰尔U检验来评估预测准确性。
在分析过程中,作者构建了用于预测药品销售的模型应用,强烈建议采用每周可及性。结果表明,采用这些计划整合方法在单个药店层面进行预测可提高准确性。
该研究涵盖了3个月的销售数据。达斯和乔杜里建议对于销售期短的产品采用36天的时间跨度。阿亚蒂等人讨论了药品销售规划的短期和长期时间跨度。坎亚尔卡尔和阿迪尔分析了多地点生产情况,并建议时间跨度应涵盖原材料交付所需的最长提前期,即12周,并选择3个月(即13周)作为短期时间跨度。翁索诺帕拉特和查韦苏克预测了1个月和12个月期间的药品销售情况并比较了结果。在本研究中,重点是短期时间跨度,即3个月,这也是最长提前期。未来,该研究可以审视其他时期。作者在研究中纳入了对八种预测方法的回顾,而未研究其他预测方法。未来的研究也可以将不同的自回归积分滑动平均(ARIMA)方法纳入短缺减少案例分析。
所提出的预测模型可能对从业者有用,他们可据此分析处方药短缺的减少情况。建议国家当局、批发商和药店对重复采购进行修订,以尽量减少短缺。
原创性/价值:为达到最高预测准确性进行分析,并确定一种能应对整个药店连锁和各独立药店每周销售波动的预测方法。该研究有助于药品销售回顾,大多数作者在此分析的是总量,未按药店区分。