Alexander Jordan D, Zhou Yuan, Freis Samantha M, Friedman Naomi P, Vrieze Scott I
Department of Psychology, University of Minnesota.
Institute for Behavioral Genetics, University of Colorado, Boulder.
J Res Pers. 2022 Oct;100. doi: 10.1016/j.jrp.2022.104277. Epub 2022 Jul 29.
Youth behavior changes and their relationships to personality have generally been investigated using self-report studies, which are subject to reporting biases and confounding variables. Supplementing these with objective measures, like GPS location data, and twin-based research designs, which help control for confounding genetic and environmental influences, may allow for more rigorous, causally informative research on adolescent behavior patterns. To investigate this possibility, this study aimed to (1) investigate whether behavior changes during the transition from adolescence to emerging adulthood are evident in changing mobility patterns, (2) estimate the influence of adolescent personality on mobility patterns, and (3) estimate genetic and environmental influences on mobility, personality, and the relationship between them. Twins aged Fourteen to twenty-two (N=709, 55% female) provided a baseline personality measure, the Big Five Inventory, and multiple years of smartphone GPS data from June 2016 - December 2019. Mobility, as measured by daily locations visited and distance travelled, was found via mixed effects models to increase during adolescence before declining slightly in emerging adulthood. Mobility was positively associated with Extraversion and Conscientiousness ( of 0.17 - 0.25, of 0.10 - 0.16) and negatively with Openness ( of -0.11 - -0.13). ACE models found large genetic (A = 0.56 - 0.81) and small-moderate environmental (C of 0.12 - 0.28, E of 0.07 - 0.15) influences on mobility. A and E influences were highly shared across mobility measures (r = 0.70, r= 0.58). Associations between mobility and personality were partially explained by mutual genetic influences (r of -0.27 - 0.53). Results show that as autonomy increases during adolescence and emerging adulthood, we see corresponding increases in youth mobility. Furthermore, the heritability of mobility patterns and their relationship to personality demonstrate that mobility patterns are informative, psychologically meaningful behaviors worthy of continued interest in psychology.
青少年行为变化及其与人格的关系通常采用自我报告研究进行调查,而这类研究容易受到报告偏差和混杂变量的影响。用客观测量方法(如GPS位置数据)以及基于双胞胎的研究设计(有助于控制混杂的遗传和环境影响)对这些研究进行补充,可能会使对青少年行为模式的研究更加严谨、更具因果信息。为了探究这种可能性,本研究旨在:(1)调查从青春期到成年早期过渡期间的行为变化是否在移动模式的改变中明显体现;(2)估计青少年人格对移动模式的影响;(3)估计遗传和环境对移动性、人格及其之间关系的影响。14至22岁的双胞胎(N = 709,55%为女性)提供了一份人格基线测量数据,即大五人格量表,以及2016年6月至2019年12月期间多年的智能手机GPS数据。通过混合效应模型发现,以每日访问地点和行进距离衡量的移动性在青春期增加,在成年早期略有下降。移动性与外向性和尽责性呈正相关(相关系数为0.17 - 0.25,p值为0.10 - 0.16),与开放性呈负相关(相关系数为 -0.11 - -0.13)。ACE模型发现遗传因素对移动性有很大影响(A = 0.56 - 0.81),环境因素有小到中等程度的影响(C为0.12 - 0.28,E为0.07 - 0.15)。遗传和环境影响在移动性测量指标中高度共享(r = 0.70,r = 0.58)。移动性与人格之间的关联部分由共同的遗传影响解释(相关系数为 -0.27 - 0.53)。结果表明,随着青少年和成年早期自主性的增加,我们看到青少年的移动性相应增加。此外,移动模式的遗传性及其与人格的关系表明,移动模式是具有信息价值、在心理上有意义的行为,值得心理学领域持续关注。