Hong Scott A, Bergman Jonathan A, Walker Ronald J, Massa Sean T
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Saint Louis University Hospital, St Louis, Missouri, USA.
Saint Louis University School of Medicine, St Louis, Missouri, USA.
OTO Open. 2022 Aug 21;6(3):2473974X221115660. doi: 10.1177/2473974X221115660. eCollection 2022 Jul-Sep.
Examine the characteristics of recent head and neck (H&N) oncology fellowship graduates and assess their current perceptions of career alignment and satisfaction.
H&N fellowship graduates from American Head and Neck Society-accredited programs between 2015 to 2020 were surveyed. Two-sample tests and analysis of variance tests were used to determine the effect of respondents' demographics, fellowship characteristics, career preferences, and current practice on their degree of career alignment with expectations and overall job satisfaction.
Fifty-eight fellowship graduates completed the cross-sectional survey. Of all respondents, 52 (89.7%) primarily preferred an academic job, of whom 5 (9.6%) went into private practice. Respondents in private practice, those treating general otolaryngology patients, and those who do not work with residents demonstrated significantly poorer job alignment and career satisfaction as compared with those in academic medicine, those treating only H&N patients, and those working with residents, respectively.
The majority of graduating H&N fellows prefer a job in academic medicine; however, there may be an insufficient number of desirable academic positions available each year to meet such demand.
By setting realistic career expectations, preparing for a mixed scope of practice, and integrating resident involvement into private practice groups, H&N providers may ultimately find more fulfillment in their work. These findings could also be valuable to the American Head and Neck Society and fellowship programs in designing training and in planning for the number of available fellowship positions each year.
研究近期头颈(H&N)肿瘤学 fellowship 毕业生的特点,并评估他们目前对职业匹配度和满意度的看法。
对 2015 年至 2020 年间毕业于美国头颈协会认可项目的 H&N fellowship 毕业生进行了调查。采用双样本检验和方差分析来确定受访者的人口统计学特征、fellowship 特点、职业偏好和当前实践对其职业匹配度与期望程度以及总体工作满意度的影响。
58 名 fellowship 毕业生完成了横断面调查。在所有受访者中,52 人(89.7%)主要倾向于学术工作,其中 5 人(9.6%)进入了私人执业领域。与从事学术医学工作的人、仅治疗 H&N 患者的人以及与住院医师一起工作的人相比,从事私人执业的受访者、治疗普通耳鼻喉科患者的受访者以及不与住院医师一起工作的受访者的工作匹配度和职业满意度明显较低。
大多数毕业的 H&N fellowship 学员更喜欢学术医学工作;然而,每年可能没有足够数量的理想学术职位来满足这种需求。
通过设定现实的职业期望、为混合的实践范围做好准备以及将住院医师的参与纳入私人执业团体,H&N 医疗服务提供者最终可能会在工作中找到更多满足感。这些发现对于美国头颈协会和 fellowship 项目在设计培训以及规划每年可用的 fellowship 职位数量方面也可能具有价值。