Doste Ruben, Lozano Miguel, Jimenez-Perez Guillermo, Mont Lluis, Berruezo Antonio, Penela Diego, Camara Oscar, Sebastian Rafael
Department of Computer Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom.
Computational Multiscale Simulation Lab (CoMMLab), Department of Computer Science, Universitat de Valencia, Valencia, Spain.
Front Physiol. 2022 Aug 12;13:909372. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2022.909372. eCollection 2022.
In order to determine the site of origin (SOO) in outflow tract ventricular arrhythmias (OTVAs) before an ablation procedure, several algorithms based on manual identification of electrocardiogram (ECG) features, have been developed. However, the reported accuracy decreases when tested with different datasets. Machine learning algorithms can automatize the process and improve generalization, but their performance is hampered by the lack of large enough OTVA databases. We propose the use of detailed electrophysiological simulations of OTVAs to train a machine learning classification model to predict the ventricular origin of the SOO of ectopic beats. We generated a synthetic database of 12-lead ECGs (2,496 signals) by running multiple simulations from the most typical OTVA SOO in 16 patient-specific geometries. Two types of input data were considered in the classification, raw and feature ECG signals. From the simulated raw 12-lead ECG, we analyzed the contribution of each lead in the predictions, keeping the best ones for the training process. For feature-based analysis, we used entropy-based methods to rank the obtained features. A cross-validation process was included to evaluate the machine learning model. Following, two clinical OTVA databases from different hospitals, including ECGs from 365 patients, were used as test-sets to assess the generalization of the proposed approach. The results show that V2 was the best lead for classification. Prediction of the SOO in OTVA, using both raw signals or features for classification, presented high accuracy values (>0.96). Generalization of the network trained on simulated data was good for both patient datasets (accuracy of 0.86 and 0.84, respectively) and presented better values than using exclusively real ECGs for classification (accuracy of 0.84 and 0.76 for each dataset). The use of simulated ECG data for training machine learning-based classification algorithms is critical to obtain good SOO predictions in OTVA compared to real data alone. The fast implementation and generalization of the proposed methodology may contribute towards its application to a clinical routine.
为了在消融手术前确定流出道室性心律失常(OTVA)的起源部位(SOO),已经开发了几种基于手动识别心电图(ECG)特征的算法。然而,当用不同数据集进行测试时,报告的准确率会下降。机器学习算法可以使这一过程自动化并提高泛化能力,但其性能受到缺乏足够大的OTVA数据库的阻碍。我们建议使用OTVA的详细电生理模拟来训练机器学习分类模型,以预测异位搏动SOO的心室起源。我们通过在16个患者特异性几何结构中从最典型的OTVA SOO运行多次模拟,生成了一个12导联心电图的合成数据库(2496个信号)。分类中考虑了两种类型的输入数据,即原始和特征心电图信号。从模拟的原始12导联心电图中,我们分析了每条导联在预测中的贡献,保留最佳导联用于训练过程。对于基于特征的分析,我们使用基于熵的方法对获得的特征进行排序。纳入了交叉验证过程来评估机器学习模型。随后,来自不同医院的两个临床OTVA数据库,包括365例患者的心电图,用作测试集来评估所提出方法的泛化能力。结果表明,V2导联是分类的最佳导联。使用原始信号或特征进行分类来预测OTVA中的SOO,都具有较高的准确率值(>0.96)。在模拟数据上训练的网络对两个患者数据集的泛化能力都很好(准确率分别为0.86和0.84),并且比仅使用真实心电图进行分类的值更好(每个数据集的准确率分别为0.84和0.76)。与仅使用真实数据相比,使用模拟心电图数据训练基于机器学习的分类算法对于在OTVA中获得良好的SOO预测至关重要。所提出方法的快速实施和泛化能力可能有助于其应用于临床常规。