Husaini Amjad M, Haq Syed Anam Ul, Shabir Asma, Wani Amir B, Dedmari Muneer A
Genome Engineering and Societal Biotechnology Lab, Division of Plant Biotechnology, Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Kashmir, Srinagar, India.
Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany.
Front Plant Sci. 2022 Aug 12;13:945291. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2022.945291. eCollection 2022.
Saffron authenticity is important for the saffron industry, consumers, food industry, and regulatory agencies. Herein we describe a combo of two novel methods to distinguish genuine saffron from fake in a user-friendly manner and without sophisticated instruments. A smartphone coupled with Foldscope was used to visualize characteristic features and distinguish "genuine" saffron from "fake." Furthermore, destaining and staining agents were used to study the staining patterns. Toluidine blue staining pattern was distinct and easier to use as it stained the papillae and the margins deep purple, while its stain is lighter yellowish green toward the central axis. Further to automate the process, we tested and compared different machine learning-based classification approaches for performing the automated saffron classification into genuine or fake. We demonstrated that the deep learning-based models are efficient in learning the morphological features and classifying samples as either fake or genuine, making it much easier for end-users. This approach performed much better than conventional machine learning approaches (random forest and SVM), and the model achieved an accuracy of 99.5% and a precision of 99.3% on the test dataset. The process has increased the robustness and reliability of authenticating saffron samples. This is the first study that describes a customer-centric frugal science-based approach to creating an automated app to detect adulteration. Furthermore, a survey was conducted to assess saffron adulteration and quality. It revealed that only 40% of samples belonged to ISO Category I, while the average adulteration percentage in the remaining samples was 36.25%. After discarding the adulterants from crude samples, their quality parameters improved significantly, elevating these from ISO category III to Category II. Conversely, it also means that Categories II and III saffron are more prone to and favored for adulteration by fraudsters.
藏红花的真伪鉴定对藏红花产业、消费者、食品行业和监管机构都很重要。在此,我们描述了两种新颖方法的组合,以一种用户友好的方式且无需复杂仪器来区分真藏红花和假藏红花。将智能手机与折叠显微镜结合使用,以可视化特征并区分“真”藏红花和“假”藏红花。此外,使用脱色剂和染色剂来研究染色模式。甲苯胺蓝染色模式独特且更易于使用,因为它将乳头和边缘染成深紫色,而朝向中轴线的染色则为较浅的黄绿色。为了使该过程自动化,我们测试并比较了不同的基于机器学习的分类方法,以将藏红花自动分类为真或假。我们证明基于深度学习的模型在学习形态特征并将样本分类为假或真方面很有效,这让终端用户操作起来容易得多。这种方法比传统的机器学习方法(随机森林和支持向量机)表现要好得多,该模型在测试数据集上的准确率达到99.5%,精确率达到99.3%。该过程提高了鉴定藏红花样本的稳健性和可靠性。这是第一项描述以客户为中心的基于节俭科学的方法来创建检测掺假的自动化应用程序的研究。此外,还进行了一项调查以评估藏红花的掺假情况和质量。结果显示,只有40%的样本属于ISO I类,而其余样本的平均掺假率为36.25%。从粗样本中去除掺假物后,其质量参数显著改善,从ISO III类提升到II类。相反,这也意味着II类和III类藏红花更容易被欺诈者掺假且更受青睐。