Zhao Xiaoli, Huang Guifang, Wu Lin, Wang Min, He Xuemin, Wang Jyun-Rong, Zhou Bin, Liu Yong, Lin Yesheng, Liu Dinghui, Yu Xianguan, Liang Suzhen, Tian Borui, Liu Linxiao, Chen Yanming, Qiu Shuhong, Xie Xujing, Han Lanqing, Qian Xiaoxian
Department of Cardiology, The Third Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
China Unicom (Guangdong) Industrial Internet Ltd., Guangzhou, China.
Front Cardiovasc Med. 2022 Aug 11;9:952089. doi: 10.3389/fcvm.2022.952089. eCollection 2022.
Current electrocardiogram (ECG) criteria of left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) have low sensitivity. Deep learning (DL) techniques have been widely used to detect cardiac diseases due to its ability of automatic feature extraction of ECG. However, DL was rarely applied in LVH diagnosis. Our study aimed to construct a DL model for rapid and effective detection of LVH using 12-lead ECG.
We built a DL model based on convolutional neural network-long short-term memory (CNN-LSTM) to detect LVH using 12-lead ECG. The echocardiogram and ECG of 1,863 patients obtained within 1 week after hospital admission were analyzed. Patients were evenly allocated into 3 sets at 3:1:1 ratio: the training set ( = 1,120), the validation set ( = 371) and the test set 1 ( = 372). In addition, we recruited 453 hospitalized patients into the internal test set 2. Different DL model of each subgroup was developed according to gender and relative wall thickness (RWT).
The LVH was predicted by the CNN-LSTM model with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.62 (sensitivity 68%, specificity 57%) in the test set 1, which outperformed Cornell voltage criteria (AUC: 0.57, sensitivity 48%, specificity 72%) and Sokolow-Lyon voltage (AUC: 0.51, sensitivity 14%, specificity 96%). In the internal test set 2, the CNN-LSTM model had a stable performance in predicting LVH with an AUC of 0.59 (sensitivity 65%, specificity 57%). In the subgroup analysis, the CNN-LSTM model predicted LVH by 12-lead ECG with an AUC of 0.66 (sensitivity 72%, specificity 60%) for male patients, which performed better than that for female patients (AUC: 0.59, sensitivity 50%, specificity 71%).
Our study established a CNN-LSTM model to diagnose LVH by 12-lead ECG with higher sensitivity than current ECG diagnostic criteria. This CNN-LSTM model may be a simple and effective screening tool of LVH.
目前左心室肥厚(LVH)的心电图(ECG)诊断标准敏感性较低。深度学习(DL)技术因其能够自动提取ECG特征,已被广泛应用于心脏疾病检测。然而,DL很少应用于LVH诊断。我们的研究旨在构建一个基于12导联ECG快速有效检测LVH的DL模型。
我们构建了一个基于卷积神经网络-长短期记忆(CNN-LSTM)的DL模型,用于利用12导联ECG检测LVH。分析了1863例患者入院后1周内获得的超声心动图和ECG。患者按3:1:1的比例均匀分为3组:训练集(n = 1120)、验证集(n = 371)和测试集1(n = 372)。此外,我们招募了453例住院患者进入内部测试集2。根据性别和相对室壁厚度(RWT)为每个亚组开发不同的DL模型。
在测试集1中,CNN-LSTM模型预测LVH的曲线下面积(AUC)为0.62(敏感性68%,特异性57%),优于Cornell电压标准(AUC:0.57,敏感性48%,特异性72%)和Sokolow-Lyon电压标准(AUC:0.51,敏感性14%,特异性96%)。在内部测试集2中,CNN-LSTM模型预测LVH的性能稳定,AUC为0.59(敏感性65%,特异性共57%)。在亚组分析中,CNN-LSTM模型通过12导联ECG预测男性患者LVH的AUC为0.66(敏感性72%,特异性60%),优于女性患者(AUC:0.59,敏感性50%,特异性71%)。
我们的研究建立了一个通过12导联ECG诊断LVH的CNN-LSTM模型,其敏感性高于当前ECG诊断标准。这个CNN-LSTM模型可能是一种简单有效的LVH筛查工具。