Lee Young-Ji, Lee Seohyun, Kim SeYeon, Choi Wonil, Jeong Yoojin, Rhim Nina Jin Joo, Seo Ilwon, Kim Sun-Young
Department of Public Health Sciences, Graduate School of Public Health, Seoul National University, Gwanak Campus, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of Global Public Administration, Yonsei University Mirae Campus, Wonju, Republic of Korea.
JMIR Med Inform. 2022 Aug 31;10(8):e29431. doi: 10.2196/29431.
Despite the increasing attention to electronic health management information systems (HMISs) in global health, most African countries still depend on inefficient paper-based systems. Good Neighbors International and Evaluate 4 Health have recently supported the Ghana Health Service on the rollout of a mobile health-based HMIS called the e-Tracker system in 2 regions in Ghana. The e-Tracker is an Android-based tracker capture app that electronically manages maternal and child health (MCH) data. The Ghana Health Service has implemented this new system in Community Health Planning and Services in the 2 regions (Volta and Eastern).
This study aims to evaluate changes in health workers' capacity and behavior after using the e-Tracker to deliver MCH services. Specifically, the study assesses the changes in knowledge, attitude, and practice (KAP) of the health workers toward the e-Tracker system by comparing the pre- and postsurvey results.
The KAP of frontline health workers was measured through self-administered surveys before and after using the e-Tracker system to assess their capacity and behavioral change toward the system. A total of 1124 health workers from the Volta and Eastern regions responded to the pre-post surveys. This study conducted the McNemar chi-square test and Wilcoxon signed-rank test for a pre-post comparison analysis. In addition, random-effects ordered logistic regression analysis and random-effects panel analysis were conducted to identify factors associated with KAP level.
The pre-post comparison analysis showed significant improvement in health workers' capacity, with higher knowledge and practice levels after using the e-Tracker system. As for knowledge, there was a 9.9%-point increase (from 559/1109, 50.41% to 669/1109, 60.32%) in the proportion of the respondents who were able to generate basic statistics on the number of children born in a random month within 30 minutes. In the practice section, the percentage of respondents who had scheduled clientencounters increased from 91.41% (968/1059) to 97.83% (1036/1059). By contrast, responses to the attitude (acceptability) became less favorable after experiencing the actual system. For instance, 48.53% (544/1121) initially expressed their preferences for an electronic system; however, the proportion decreased to 33.45% (375/1121) after the intervention. Random-effects ordered logistic regression showed that days of overwork were significantly associated with health workers' attitudes toward the e-Tracker system.
This study provides empirical evidence that the e-Tracker system is conducive to enhancing capacity in MCH data management for providing necessary MCH services. However, the change in attitude implies that the users appear to feel less comfortable using the new system. As Ghana plans to scale up the electronic HMIS system using the e-Tracker to the national level, strategies to enhance health workers' attitudes are necessary to sustain this new system.
尽管全球卫生领域对电子健康管理信息系统(HMISs)的关注日益增加,但大多数非洲国家仍依赖效率低下的纸质系统。国际善邻会和“评估促进健康”组织最近支持加纳卫生服务局在加纳的两个地区推广一种基于移动健康的HMIS,即电子追踪系统。电子追踪器是一款基于安卓系统的追踪器捕获应用程序,可对孕产妇和儿童健康(MCH)数据进行电子管理。加纳卫生服务局已在这两个地区(沃尔特和东部)的社区卫生规划与服务中实施了这一新系统。
本研究旨在评估使用电子追踪器提供妇幼保健服务后卫生工作者能力和行为的变化。具体而言,该研究通过比较调查前后的结果,评估卫生工作者对电子追踪器系统的知识、态度和实践(KAP)的变化。
通过在使用电子追踪器系统前后进行的自我管理调查,测量一线卫生工作者的KAP,以评估他们对该系统的能力和行为变化。来自沃尔特和东部地区的1124名卫生工作者对前后调查做出了回应。本研究进行了McNemar卡方检验和Wilcoxon符号秩检验,用于前后比较分析。此外,还进行了随机效应有序逻辑回归分析和随机效应面板分析,以确定与KAP水平相关的因素。
前后比较分析显示,卫生工作者的能力有显著提高,使用电子追踪器系统后的知识和实践水平更高。在知识方面,能够在30分钟内生成随机月份出生儿童数量基本统计数据的受访者比例增加了9.9个百分点(从559/1109,50.41%增至669/1109,60.32%)。在实践方面,安排客户预约的受访者比例从91.41%(968/1059)增至97.83%(1036/1059)。相比之下,在体验实际系统后,对态度(可接受性)的回应变得不那么积极。例如,48.53%(544/1121)的人最初表示更喜欢电子系统;然而,干预后这一比例降至33.45%(375/1121)。随机效应有序逻辑回归显示,加班天数与卫生工作者对电子追踪器系统的态度显著相关。
本研究提供了实证证据,表明电子追踪器系统有助于提高妇幼保健数据管理能力,以提供必要的妇幼保健服务。然而,态度的变化意味着用户在使用新系统时似乎感觉不那么舒适。由于加纳计划将使用电子追踪器的电子HMIS系统扩大到全国范围,因此有必要采取策略来增强卫生工作者的态度,以维持这一新系统。