Maluf Fernando Cotait, Dal Molin Graziela Zibetti, de Melo Andreia Cristina, Paulino Eduardo, Racy Douglas, Ferrigno Robson, Uson Junior Pedro Luiz Serrano, Ribeiro Reitan, Moretti Renato, Sadalla Jose Carlos, Nogueira-Rodrigues Angelica, Carvalho Filomena Marino, Baiocchi Glauco, Callegaro-Filho Donato, Abu-Rustum Nadeem R
Hospital Beneficiência Portuguesa (BP) Mirante, São Paulo, Brazil.
Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, São Paulo, Brazil.
Front Oncol. 2022 Aug 18;12:928560. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.928560. eCollection 2022.
Nearly 85% of cervical cancer new cases are diagnosed in limited resources countries. Although several strategies have been proposed to reduce the disease burden, challenges remain to provide the best possible care. We report recommendations from an expert consensus meeting convened to address from prevention to management of cervical cancer in limited resources countries.
The expert panel, composed by invited specialists from 38 developing countries in Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe, Latin America, and the Middle East, convened in Rio de Janeiro in September 2019, during the Global Meeting of the International Gynecological Cancer Society (IGCS). Panel members considered the published scientific evidence and their practical experience on the topics, as well as the perceived cost-effectiveness of, and access to, the available interventions. The focus of the recommendations was on geographic regions rather than entire countries because medical practice varies considerably in the countries represented. Resource limitation was qualified as limited access to qualified surgeons, contemporary imaging or radiation-oncology techniques, antineoplastic drugs, or overall funding for provision of state-of-the-art care. Consensus was defined as at least 75% of the voting members selecting a particular answer of the multiple-choice questionnaire, whereas the majority vote was considered as 50% to 74.9%.
Consensus was reached for 25 of the 121 (20.7%) questions, whereas for 54 (44.6%) questions there was one option garnering between 50% to 74.9% of votes (majority votes). For the remaining questions, considerable heterogeneity in responses was observed.
The implementation of international guidelines is challenging in countries with resource limitations or unique health-care landscapes. The development of guidelines by the health care providers in those regions is more reflective of the reality on the ground and may improve medical practice and patient care. However, challenges remain toward achieving that goal at political, economic, social, and medical levels.
近85%的宫颈癌新发病例在资源有限的国家被诊断出来。尽管已经提出了几种策略来减轻疾病负担,但在提供尽可能最佳的护理方面仍存在挑战。我们报告了一次专家共识会议的建议,该会议旨在探讨资源有限国家宫颈癌从预防到管理的各个方面。
专家小组由来自非洲、亚洲、东欧、拉丁美洲和中东38个发展中国家的特邀专家组成,于2019年9月在里约热内卢召开会议,当时正值国际妇科癌症协会(IGCS)全球会议期间。小组成员考虑了已发表的科学证据、他们在这些主题上的实践经验,以及可用干预措施的成本效益和可及性。建议的重点是地理区域而非整个国家,因为所代表国家的医疗实践差异很大。资源限制被定义为难以获得合格的外科医生、现代成像或放射肿瘤学技术、抗肿瘤药物,或提供先进护理的总体资金。共识被定义为至少75%的投票成员选择多项选择题中的特定答案,而多数票被视为50%至74.9%。
121个问题中有25个(20.7%)达成了共识,而54个(44.6%)问题中有一个选项获得了50%至74.9%的选票(多数票)。对于其余问题,观察到回答存在相当大的异质性。
在资源有限或医疗保健情况独特的国家,实施国际指南具有挑战性。这些地区的医疗保健提供者制定的指南更能反映当地实际情况,可能会改善医疗实践和患者护理。然而,在政治、经济、社会和医疗层面实现这一目标仍存在挑战。