Cueille Raphael, Lavandier Mathieu, Grimault Nicolas
Univ. Lyon, ENTPE, Ecole Centrale de Lyon, CNRS, LTDS, UMR5513, Vaulx-en-Velin 69518, France.
CRNL, UMR CNRS 5292, Univ. Lyon 1, 50 av T Garnier, Lyon Cedex 07 69366, France.
R Soc Open Sci. 2022 Aug 31;9(8):210342. doi: 10.1098/rsos.210342. eCollection 2022 Aug.
Reverberation can have a strong detrimental effect on speech intelligibility in noise. Two main monaural effects were studied here: the temporal smearing of the target speech, which makes the speech less understandable, and the temporal smearing of the noise, which reduces the opportunity for listening in the masker dips. These phenomena have been shown to affect normal-hearing (NH) listeners. The aim of this study was to understand whether hearing-impaired (HI) listeners are more affected by reverberation, and if so to identify which of these two effects is responsible. They were investigated separately and in combination, by applying reverberation either on the target speech, on the noise masker, or on both sources. Binaural effects were not investigated here. Intelligibility scores in the presence of stationary and modulated noise were systematically compared for both NH and HI listeners in these situations. At the optimal signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) (that is to say, the SNRs with the least amount of floor and ceiling effects), the temporal smearing of both the speech and the noise had a similar effect for the HI and NH listeners, so that reverberation was not more detrimental for the HI listeners. There was only a very limited dip listening benefit at this SNR for either group. Some differences across group appeared at the SNR maximizing dip listening, but they could not be directly related to an effect of reverberation, and were rather due to floor effects or to the reduced ability of the HI listeners to benefit from dip listening, even in the absence of reverberation.
混响会对噪声环境下的言语可懂度产生强烈的不利影响。本文研究了两种主要的单耳效应:目标言语的时间拖尾,这会使言语更难理解;以及噪声的时间拖尾,这会减少在掩蔽声间隙中聆听的机会。这些现象已被证明会影响听力正常(NH)的听众。本研究的目的是了解听力受损(HI)的听众是否更容易受到混响的影响,如果是,则确定这两种效应中哪一种起作用。通过分别对目标言语、噪声掩蔽声或两者同时施加混响,对这两种效应进行了单独和综合的研究。本文未研究双耳效应。系统地比较了在这些情况下NH和HI听众在存在稳态噪声和调制噪声时的可懂度得分。在最佳信噪比(SNR)(即具有最小底限和上限效应的SNR)下,言语和噪声的时间拖尾对HI和NH听众的影响相似,因此混响对HI听众的危害并不更大。在这个SNR下,两组听众的间隙聆听益处都非常有限。在使间隙聆听最大化的SNR下,两组之间出现了一些差异,但这些差异不能直接归因于混响效应,而更可能是由于底限效应或HI听众即使在没有混响的情况下也难以从间隙聆听中受益。