Department of Orthopedics, Columbia University, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Department of Neurology, Columbia University, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Brain. 2022 Dec 19;145(12):4531-4544. doi: 10.1093/brain/awac235.
Associative plasticity occurs when two stimuli converge on a common neural target. Previous efforts to promote associative plasticity have targeted cortex, with variable and moderate effects. In addition, the targeted circuits are inferred, rather than tested directly. In contrast, we sought to target the strong convergence between motor and sensory systems in the spinal cord. We developed spinal cord associative plasticity, precisely timed pairing of motor cortex and dorsal spinal cord stimulations, to target this interaction. We tested the hypothesis that properly timed paired stimulation would strengthen the sensorimotor connections in the spinal cord and improve recovery after spinal cord injury. We tested physiological effects of paired stimulation, the pathways that mediate it, and its function in a preclinical trial. Subthreshold spinal cord stimulation strongly augmented motor cortex evoked muscle potentials at the time they were paired, but only when they arrived synchronously in the spinal cord. This paired stimulation effect depended on both cortical descending motor and spinal cord proprioceptive afferents; selective inactivation of either of these pathways fully abrogated the paired stimulation effect. Spinal cord associative plasticity, repetitive pairing of these pathways for 5 or 30 min in awake rats, increased spinal excitability for hours after pairing ended. To apply spinal cord associative plasticity as therapy, we optimized the parameters to promote strong and long-lasting effects. This effect was just as strong in rats with cervical spinal cord injury as in uninjured rats, demonstrating that spared connections after moderate spinal cord injury were sufficient to support plasticity. In a blinded trial, rats received a moderate C4 contusive spinal cord injury. Ten days after injury, they were randomized to 30 min of spinal cord associative plasticity each day for 10 days or sham stimulation. Rats with spinal cord associative plasticity had significantly improved function on the primary outcome measure, a test of dexterity during manipulation of food, at 50 days after spinal cord injury. In addition, rats with spinal cord associative plasticity had persistently stronger responses to cortical and spinal stimulation than sham stimulation rats, indicating a spinal locus of plasticity. After spinal cord associative plasticity, rats had near normalization of H-reflex modulation. The groups had no difference in the rat grimace scale, a measure of pain. We conclude that spinal cord associative plasticity strengthens sensorimotor connections within the spinal cord, resulting in partial recovery of reflex modulation and forelimb function after moderate spinal cord injury. Since both motor cortex and spinal cord stimulation are performed routinely in humans, this approach can be trialled in people with spinal cord injury or other disorders that damage sensorimotor connections and impair dexterity.
当两个刺激会聚到共同的神经靶点时,就会发生联想性可塑性。以前促进联想性可塑性的努力都集中在皮层上,效果是可变的且适中的。此外,靶向的回路是推断出来的,而不是直接测试的。相比之下,我们试图靶向脊髓中运动和感觉系统之间的强会聚。我们开发了脊髓联想性可塑性,即精确地对大脑皮层和脊髓背侧进行刺激配对,以靶向这种相互作用。我们检验了这样一种假设,即正确定时的配对刺激会增强脊髓中的感觉运动连接,并改善脊髓损伤后的恢复。我们检验了生理效应、介导它的途径以及它在临床前试验中的功能。脊髓刺激的阈下刺激在它们配对时强烈增强了运动皮层诱发的肌肉电位,但仅当它们同步到达脊髓时才会发生这种情况。这种配对刺激效应取决于皮质下行运动和脊髓本体感受传入;这些通路中的任何一条的选择性失活都完全消除了配对刺激效应。脊髓联想性可塑性,即对清醒大鼠的这些通路进行 5 或 30 分钟的重复配对,可在配对结束后数小时内增加脊髓兴奋性。为了将脊髓联想性可塑性作为一种治疗方法应用,我们优化了参数以促进强烈而持久的效果。在中度脊髓损伤的大鼠中,这种效果与未受伤的大鼠一样强烈,这表明中度脊髓损伤后的剩余连接足以支持可塑性。在一项盲法试验中,大鼠接受了 C4 挫伤性脊髓损伤。损伤后 10 天,它们被随机分为每天接受 30 分钟脊髓联想性可塑性治疗或假刺激治疗 10 天。接受脊髓联想性可塑性治疗的大鼠在脊髓损伤后 50 天的主要疗效测量中,即在操作食物时的灵巧性测试中,功能显著改善。此外,接受脊髓联想性可塑性治疗的大鼠对皮质和脊髓刺激的反应比接受假刺激治疗的大鼠要强得多,这表明了脊髓可塑性的位置。在接受脊髓联想性可塑性治疗后,大鼠的 H 反射调制接近正常化。两组在大鼠面部表情量表(一种衡量疼痛的量表)上没有差异。我们的结论是,脊髓联想性可塑性增强了脊髓内的感觉运动连接,导致中度脊髓损伤后的反射调制和前肢功能部分恢复。由于大脑皮层和脊髓刺激在人类中常规进行,因此这种方法可以在脊髓损伤或其他损伤感觉运动连接并损害灵巧性的疾病患者中进行试验。