Yadlin Aya, Marciano Avi
Hadassah Academic College, Israel.
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel.
Mob Media Commun. 2022 Sep;10(3):421-447. doi: 10.1177/20501579211068269.
In March 2020, Israel passed emergency regulations authorizing its internal security agency to track citizens' mobile phone geolocations in order to tackle the spread of COVID-19. This unprecedented surveillance enterprise attracted extensive media attention and sparked a vigorous public debate regarding technology and democratic values such as privacy, mobility, and control. This article examines press coverage of Israel's surveillance of its citizens during the COVID-19 pandemic by four leading news sites to identify and map the frames that informed their reports. Based on a thematic analysis, our findings point to supportive and critical constructions of mobile phone location-tracking and organize them within two scapes: personal; and international. These attest to the collective imagining of intimacies and public life, respectively. We draw on the case study to articulate mobile phones as devices that reduce movement into manageable mapped information and individuals into controllable data. Mobile phone location-tracking during the COVID-19 pandemic is understood as turning mobility into order and control.
2020年3月,以色列通过了紧急法规,授权其国内安全机构追踪公民的手机地理位置,以应对新冠疫情的传播。这一史无前例的监控行动引起了媒体的广泛关注,并引发了一场关于技术与隐私、流动性和控制权等民主价值观的激烈公众辩论。本文通过四家主要新闻网站对以色列在新冠疫情期间对公民的监控进行了新闻报道分析,以识别并梳理出影响其报道的框架。基于主题分析,我们的研究结果指出了对手机位置追踪的支持性和批判性建构,并将它们组织在两个层面:个人层面和国际层面。这些分别证明了对亲密关系和公共生活的集体想象。我们利用这个案例研究来阐明手机作为一种将移动转化为可管理的地图信息、将个人转化为可控数据的设备。新冠疫情期间的手机位置追踪被理解为将流动性转化为秩序和控制。