Dissen Anthony, Qadiri Qudratullah, Middleton Charles J
Stockton University, Galloway, New Jersey.
Am J Lifestyle Med. 2021 Feb 19;16(5):641-654. doi: 10.1177/1559827621990574. eCollection 2022 Sep-Oct.
Online sources of health information are a significant means by which the public educates itself about health and wellness. The purpose of this study is to investigate how undergraduate students evaluate and assess health-related websites for accuracy, as well as the self-reported factors used in identifying whether a website is an accurate source of information. One hundred and fifty-seven students participated by reviewing a series of 10 health-related websites and indicated whether they believed the website to be an accurate source of health information. Students completed an open-ended question to self-report how they made this determination. Results indicate that students were not able to accurately distinguish between credible sources of web-based health information and those sources that were previously categorized as not being credible sources. Analysis of self-reported qualitative feedback gave rise to 6 factors used to determine the accuracy of the websites reviewed. While students report using these factors, and these factors are consistent with previous research, this does not appear then to be translating to successful determination of a source's accuracy. Educating students in proper fact-checking and evaluation skills may be warranted to develop a generation of individuals who can be said to have better health literacy.
在线健康信息来源是公众自我学习健康与保健知识的重要途径。本研究旨在调查本科生如何评估与判断健康相关网站的准确性,以及他们在识别网站是否为准确信息来源时自我报告所使用的因素。157名学生参与了此次研究,他们浏览了一系列10个与健康相关的网站,并指出他们是否认为该网站是健康信息的准确来源。学生们完成了一个开放式问题,以自我报告他们是如何做出这一判断的。结果表明,学生们无法准确区分基于网络的可靠健康信息来源和那些先前被归类为不可靠的来源。对自我报告的定性反馈进行分析后,得出了用于确定所浏览网站准确性的6个因素。虽然学生们报告使用了这些因素,且这些因素与先前的研究一致,但这似乎并未转化为成功判断信息来源的准确性。或许有必要对学生进行适当的事实核查和评估技能教育,以培养出一代具有更高健康素养的人。