Zhang Chenghao, Ji Ling, Li Yijun, Pan Fangwei, Liao Wen, Zhao Zhihe
State Key Laboratory of Oral Diseases & National Clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases, Department of Orthodontics, West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China.
State Key Laboratory of Oral Diseases & National Clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases, West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China.
J Clin Med. 2022 Sep 4;11(17):5229. doi: 10.3390/jcm11175229.
The objective of this study was to propose a method that combines a maxilla-based coordinate system and mandibular voxel-based superimposition for an accurate evaluation of mandibular structural and positional changes and a direct comparison between maxillary and mandibular structural changes with the same 3D vectors.
Mandibular voxel-based superimposition was firstly performed to reorient the mandibles and eliminate the mandibular positional changes. Then, a maxilla-based coordinate system was constructed with four maxillary skeletal landmarks (ANS, PNS, OrL and OrR). After settling the reoriented mandibles into this coordinate system, the mandibular structural changes were accurately evaluated. To assess the accuracy and reproducibility of this method, CBCT images of a skull specimen before and after orthodontic treatment (which was simulated by rearranging the skull and the mandible) were collected. Five mandibular skeletal landmarks, three mandibular dental landmarks and two mandibular measurement planes of this skull were used to evaluate the linear and angular changes in the mandibular structures.
There were significant differences in the linear and angular measurements of the mandibular structures of the skull ( ˂ 0.05), which indicated mandibular positional changes after orthodontic treatment. After mandibular voxel-based superimposition, there were no significant differences in the linear and angular measurements of mandibular structures, which indicated that the mandibular positional changes were eliminated. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) value of the inter- and intra-observer agreement of all measurements was 0.99.
This method has proven advantages in terms of accuracy, reproducibility and validity; with this method, mandibular structural and positional changes can be accurately evaluated and maxillary and mandibular structural changes can be directly compared with same 3D vectors.
本研究的目的是提出一种方法,该方法结合基于上颌的坐标系和基于下颌体素的叠加技术,以准确评估下颌的结构和位置变化,并使用相同的三维向量对上颌和下颌的结构变化进行直接比较。
首先进行基于下颌体素的叠加,以重新定位下颌并消除下颌的位置变化。然后,利用四个上颌骨骨骼标志点(前鼻棘、后鼻棘、左眶点和右眶点)构建基于上颌的坐标系。将重新定位后的下颌放入该坐标系后,准确评估下颌的结构变化。为了评估该方法的准确性和可重复性,收集了正畸治疗前后(通过重新排列颅骨和下颌骨模拟)的颅骨标本的锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)图像。使用该颅骨的五个下颌骨骨骼标志点、三个下颌牙齿标志点和两个下颌测量平面来评估下颌结构的线性和角度变化。
颅骨下颌结构的线性和角度测量存在显著差异(<0.05),这表明正畸治疗后下颌位置发生了变化。基于下颌体素的叠加后,下颌结构的线性和角度测量无显著差异,这表明下颌位置变化已消除。所有测量的观察者间和观察者内一致性的组内相关系数(ICC)值为0.99。
该方法在准确性、可重复性和有效性方面已证明具有优势;使用该方法,可以准确评估下颌的结构和位置变化,并使用相同的三维向量直接比较上颌和下颌的结构变化。