Nyberg Andre, Milad Nadia, Martin Mickael, Patoine Dany, Morissette Mathieu C, Saey Didier, Maltais François
Institut Universitaire de Cardiologie et de Pneumologie de Québec, Université Laval, Québec, QC, Canada.
Department of Community Medicine and Rehabilitation, section of Physiotherapy, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Front Physiol. 2022 Aug 23;13:873465. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2022.873465. eCollection 2022.
Quadriceps dysfunction is a common systemic manifestation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), for which treatment using resistance training is highly recommended. Even though training volume is suggested to be a key explanatory factor for intramuscular adaptation to resistance training in healthy older adults, knowledge is scarce on the role of progression of training volume for intramuscular adaptations in COPD. This study was a sub-analysis of a parallel-group randomized controlled trial. Thirteen patients with severe to very severe COPD (median 66 yrs, forced expiratory volume in 1 s 44% predicted) performed 8 weeks of low-load resistance training. In a analysis, they were divided into two groups according to their training volume progression. Those in whom training volume continued to increase after the first 4 weeks of training outlined the continued progression group ( = 9), while those with limited increase (<5%) or even reduction in training volume after the initial 4 weeks composed the discontinued progression group ( = 4). Fiber-type distribution and oxidative muscle protein levels, i.e., citrate synthase (CS), hydroxyacyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase (HADH), mitochondrial transcription factor A (TfAM) as well as quadriceps endurance measures (total work from elastic band and isokinetic knee extension tests), were assessed before and after the intervention period. The continued progression group sustained their training volume progression during weeks 5-8 compared to weeks 1-4 (median +25%), while the discontinued progression group did not (median -2%) ( = 0.007 between groups). Compared with baseline values, significant between-group differences in fiber type distribution and TfAM muscle protein levels (range ± 17-62%, < 0.05) and in individual responses to change in Type I and Type IIa fiber type proportion, CS, HADH, and TfAM muscle protein levels outcomes (median 89 vs. 50%, = 0.001) were seen in favor of the continued progression group. Moreover, only the continued progression group had a significant increase in HADH muscle protein levels (+24%, = 0.004), elastic band (+56%, = 0.004) and isokinetic (+7%, = 0.004) quadriceps endurance, but the between-group differences did not reach statistical significance (range 14-29%, = 0.330-1.000). The novel findings of the current study were that patients with COPD who had a continued progression of training volume across the 8-weeks intervention had an increased proportion of Type I fibers, and TfAM muscle protein levels and decreased proportion of Type II fibers compared to those that did not continue to progress their training volume after the initial weeks. Additionally, HADH muscle protein levels and quadriceps endurance measurements only improved in the continued progression group, although no significant between-group differences were seen. These findings highlight the importance of continued progression of training volume during resistive training to counteract quadriceps dysfunction within the COPD population. Still, considering the small sample size and the nature of our analyses, these results should be interpreted cautiously, and further research is necessary.
股四头肌功能障碍是慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)常见的全身表现,对此强烈建议采用阻力训练进行治疗。尽管训练量被认为是健康老年人肌肉对阻力训练适应性的关键解释因素,但关于COPD患者肌肉适应性训练量进展的作用,我们所知甚少。本研究是一项平行组随机对照试验的子分析。13例重度至极重度COPD患者(中位年龄66岁,第1秒用力呼气量为预测值的44%)进行了8周的低负荷阻力训练。在一项分析中,根据训练量进展情况将他们分为两组。在训练的前4周后训练量持续增加的患者被归为持续进展组(n = 9),而在最初4周后训练量增加有限(<5%)甚至减少的患者则组成非持续进展组(n = 4)。在干预期前后评估了纤维类型分布和氧化型肌肉蛋白水平,即柠檬酸合酶(CS)、羟酰辅酶A脱氢酶(HADH)、线粒体转录因子A(TfAM)以及股四头肌耐力指标(弹力带和等速膝关节伸展试验的总功)。与第1 - 4周相比,持续进展组在第5 - 8周维持了训练量进展(中位增加25%),而非持续进展组则没有(中位减少2%)(两组间P = 0.007)。与基线值相比,在纤维类型分布和TfAM肌肉蛋白水平(范围±17 - 62%,P < 0.05)以及I型和IIa型纤维类型比例、CS、HADH和TfAM肌肉蛋白水平结果的个体变化反应方面(中位89%对50%,P = 0.001),两组间存在显著差异,持续进展组更具优势。此外,只有持续进展组的HADH肌肉蛋白水平有显著增加(+24%,P = 0.004),弹力带(+56%,P = 0.004)和等速(+7%,P = 0.004)股四头肌耐力增加,但两组间差异未达到统计学意义(范围14 - 29%,P = 0.330 - 1.000)。本研究的新发现是,与在最初几周后训练量未持续进展的患者相比,在8周干预期间训练量持续进展的COPD患者I型纤维比例增加,TfAM肌肉蛋白水平升高,II型纤维比例降低。此外,只有持续进展组的HADH肌肉蛋白水平和股四头肌耐力测量值有所改善,尽管两组间无显著差异。这些发现凸显了在阻力训练期间持续增加训练量对于抵消COPD患者股四头肌功能障碍的重要性。不过,考虑到样本量较小以及我们分析的性质,这些结果应谨慎解读,还需要进一步研究。