Cooper Julie B, Scotti Alice, Carr Megan L
Department of Clinical Sciences, Fred Wilson School of Pharmacy, High Point University, 1 University Parkway, High Point, NC, 27268, United States.
Res Social Adm Pharm. 2023 Jan;19(1):16-27. doi: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2022.08.013. Epub 2022 Aug 20.
The rising cost of medications has a disproportionate effect on community-dwelling older adults despite policy changes designed to improve medication access. Medicare insurance counseling provided by pharmacists, including individualized plan comparison and enrollment assistance, improves medication adherence and health care utilization, yet only 15% of community dwelling older adults report using a pharmacy or pharmacist for Medicare information. To determine what information is available to inform expanding implementation of pharmacy as a resource for Medicare insurance counseling, a systematic review of published studies using the RE-AIM (Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance) framework was conducted.
Articles meeting inclusion criteria were identified through a literature search using PubMed and GoogleScholar; 27 pharmacy Medicare insurance counseling studies were identified representing 13 unique programs in clinical, community outreach, and community pharmacy settings. Each article was coded by two researchers using the RE-AIM Coding Sheet for Publications and the extent of RE-AIM dimension reporting was determined using descriptive statistics at the program level. Discussions were used to arrive at coding consensus and concordance was measured with Krippendorff's alpha.
Across all studies (15 quasi experimental, 10 analytical case reports, and 2 case reports) more than half of the programs reported framework component dimensions for Reach (69%), Adoption (58%), Implementation (54%), and Maintenance (54%), and fewer than half reported comprehensively on Effectiveness (44%). Ten studies in 7 of 13 programs reported estimated out-of-pocket cost savings. Two studies measured patient-centered outcomes: medication adherence by proportion of days covered (PDC) and health care utilization by hospital admissions and emergency department visits. Gaps in the external validity of pharmacy Medicare education programs were identified including staff participation rates, methods to identify participating settings and program costs.
Based on this review, current research on pharmacy Medicare education is insufficient to guide broad implementation. Additional studies are needed to determine how Medicare education integrating pharmacists and pharmacies can be implemented to address cost-related non-adherence for community dwelling older adults.
尽管出台了旨在改善药物获取的政策变化,但药物成本的上升对居家老年人产生了不成比例的影响。药剂师提供的医疗保险咨询服务,包括个性化的计划比较和参保协助,可提高药物依从性和医疗保健利用率,但只有15%的居家老年人表示利用药房或药剂师获取医疗保险信息。为了确定哪些信息可用于指导扩大药房作为医疗保险咨询资源的实施,我们使用RE-AIM(覆盖范围、有效性、采用率、实施情况和维持情况)框架对已发表的研究进行了系统综述。
通过使用PubMed和Google Scholar进行文献检索,确定符合纳入标准的文章;共识别出27项药房医疗保险咨询研究,代表了临床、社区外展和社区药房环境中的13个独特项目。两名研究人员使用出版物的RE-AIM编码表对每篇文章进行编码,并在项目层面使用描述性统计方法确定RE-AIM维度报告的程度。通过讨论达成编码共识,并用Krippendorff's alpha测量一致性。
在所有研究中(15项准实验研究、10项分析性病例报告和2项病例报告),超过一半的项目报告了覆盖范围(69%)、采用率(58%)、实施情况(54%)和维持情况(54%)的框架组成部分维度,不到一半的项目全面报告了有效性(44%)。13个项目中的7个项目的10项研究报告了估计的自付费用节省情况。两项研究测量了以患者为中心的结果:按覆盖天数比例(PDC)衡量的药物依从性以及按住院和急诊就诊次数衡量的医疗保健利用率。确定了药房医疗保险教育项目外部有效性方面的差距,包括工作人员参与率以及确定参与机构和项目成本的方法。
基于本次综述,目前关于药房医疗保险教育的研究不足以指导广泛实施。需要更多研究来确定如何实施整合药剂师和药房的医疗保险教育,以解决居家老年人与成本相关的不依从问题。