Department of Cell and Developmental Biology, School of Biological Sciences, University of California San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093.
Program in Biological Sciences, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60201.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2022 Dec;21(4):ar66. doi: 10.1187/cbe.20-08-0170.
Bloom's taxonomy is a classification of learning objectives originally developed for general educational purposes. The taxonomy was revised to expand beyond cognitive processes and to include knowledge types as an orthogonal dimension. As Bloom's taxonomy is a tool widely used in biology education by researchers and instructors, it is important to examine the underlying assumptions embedded within how people may implicitly understand and use the taxonomy. In this paper, we empirically examine two major assumptions: the independence of the knowledge-type and cognitive-process dimensions and the use of action verbs as proxies for different cognitive processes. Contingency analysis on 940 assessment items revealed that the knowledge-type and cognitive-process dimensions are related and not independent. Subsequent correspondence analysis identified two principle axes in how the two dimensions are related, with three clusters of knowledge types and cognitive processes. Using the Shannon evenness index, we did not find a clear relationship between question prompt words (including action verbs) and cognitive processes in the assessment items. Based on these results, we suggest that both dimensions of the revised Bloom's taxonomy should be used and that question prompt words or action verbs alone are not sufficient in classifying the embedded learning objectives within assessment items.
布鲁姆教育目标分类学是一种学习目标分类法,最初是为一般教育目的而开发的。该分类法经过修订,不仅扩展了认知过程,还将知识类型作为一个正交维度包括在内。由于布鲁姆教育目标分类学是研究人员和教师在生物学教育中广泛使用的工具,因此,重要的是要检查人们可能隐含地理解和使用该分类法所依据的基本假设。在本文中,我们通过实证检验了两个主要假设:知识类型和认知过程维度的独立性以及使用动作动词作为不同认知过程的代理。对 940 个评估项目的条件分析表明,知识类型和认知过程维度是相关的,而不是独立的。随后的对应分析确定了这两个维度相关的两个主要轴,以及知识类型和认知过程的三个聚类。使用香农均匀度指数,我们没有发现评估项目中的问题提示词(包括动作动词)与认知过程之间有明显的关系。基于这些结果,我们建议应该同时使用修订后的布鲁姆教育目标分类学的两个维度,并且问题提示词或动作动词本身不足以对评估项目中嵌入的学习目标进行分类。