Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka University, 2-2 Yamadaoka, Suita, Osaka, 565-0871, Japan.
Department of Artificial Intelligence Diagnostic Radiology, Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka University, Suita, Osaka, Japan.
Sci Rep. 2022 Sep 21;12(1):15732. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-19914-x.
Cervical sagittal alignment is an essential parameter for the evaluation of spine disorders. Manual measurement is time-consuming and burdensome to measurers. Artificial intelligence (AI) in the form of convolutional neural networks has begun to be used to measure x-rays. This study aimed to develop AI for automated measurement of lordosis on lateral cervical x-rays. We included 4546 cervical x-rays from 1674 patients. For all x-rays, the caudal endplates of C2 and C7 were labeled based on consensus among well-experienced spine surgeons, the data for which were used as ground truth. This ground truth was split into training data and test data, and the AI model learned the training data. The absolute error of the AI measurements relative to the ground truth for 4546 x-rays was determined by fivefold cross-validation. Additionally, the absolute error of AI measurements was compared with the error of other 2 surgeons' measurements on 415 radiographs of 168 randomly selected patients. In fivefold cross-validation, the absolute error of the AI model was 3.3° in the average and 2.2° in the median. For comparison of other surgeons, the mean absolute error for measurement of 168 patients was 3.1° ± 3.4° for the AI model, 3.9° ± 3.4° for Surgeon 1, and 3.8° ± 4.7° for Surgeon 2. The AI model had a significantly smaller error than Surgeon 1 and Surgeon 2 (P = 0.002 and 0.036). This algorithm is available at ( https://ykszk.github.io/c2c7demo/ ). The AI model measured cervical spine alignment with better accuracy than surgeons. AI can assist in routine medical care and can be helpful in research that measures large numbers of images. However, because of the large errors in rare cases such as highly deformed ones, AI may, in principle, be limited to assisting humans.
颈椎矢状位排列是评估脊柱疾病的一个基本参数。手工测量既费时又费力。以卷积神经网络形式存在的人工智能已开始用于 X 射线测量。本研究旨在开发一种用于自动测量侧位颈椎 X 射线的脊柱前凸的人工智能。我们纳入了来自 1674 名患者的 4546 张颈椎 X 射线片。对于所有 X 射线片,C2 和 C7 的尾端椎板均根据经验丰富的脊柱外科医生的共识进行标记,这些数据作为真实数据。该真实数据被分为训练数据和测试数据,人工智能模型学习训练数据。通过五重交叉验证确定 4546 张 X 射线片的人工智能测量结果与真实数据的绝对误差。此外,还比较了人工智能测量结果的绝对误差与另外 2 位外科医生对 168 名随机选择的患者的 415 张 X 射线片的测量误差。在五重交叉验证中,人工智能模型的平均绝对误差为 3.3°,中位数为 2.2°。对于其他外科医生的比较,人工智能模型对 168 名患者的测量平均绝对误差为 3.1°±3.4°,外科医生 1 的为 3.9°±3.4°,外科医生 2 的为 3.8°±4.7°。人工智能模型的误差明显小于外科医生 1 和外科医生 2(P=0.002 和 0.036)。该算法可在(https://ykszk.github.io/c2c7demo/)获得。人工智能模型测量颈椎脊柱排列的准确性优于外科医生。人工智能可以辅助常规医疗,并且有助于测量大量图像的研究。然而,由于在高度变形等罕见情况下存在较大误差,人工智能原则上可能仅限于辅助人类。