Johnston Aaron, Malhi Rebecca, Cofie Nicholas, Jokic Ruzica, Goertzen James, Smith-Windsor Tom, Makwarimba Edward, Girouard Marie-Hélène, Badcock Sandra, Bell Amanda
Distributed Learning and Rural Initiatives, Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, T2N 4Z6, Canada.
Professional Development and Educational Scholarship, Queen's University, Faculty of Health Sciences, Kingston, Ontario, K7L 0E9, Canada.
MedEdPublish (2016). 2022 Mar 1;12:12. doi: 10.12688/mep.17540.1. eCollection 2022.
: Medical schools spend considerable time, effort, and money on recognition initiatives for rural and distributed medical education (DME) faculty. Previous literature has focused on intrinsic motivation to teach and there is little in the literature to guide institutional recognition efforts or to predict which items or types of recognition will be most appreciated. To better understand how rural and DME faculty in Canada value different forms of recognition, we asked faculty members from all Canadian medical schools to complete a bilingual, national online survey evaluating their perceptions of currently offered rewards and recognition. The survey received a robust response in both English and French, across nine Canadian provinces and one territory. Our results indicated that there were three distinct ways that preceptors looked at recognition; these perspectives were consistent across geographic and demographic variables. These "clusters" or "currencies of recognition" included: i) Formal institutional recognition, ii) connections, growth and development, and iii) tokens of gratitude. Financial recognition was also found to be important but separate from the three clusters. Some preceptors did value support of intrinsic motivation most important, and for others extrinsic motivators, or a mix of both was most valued. Study results will help medical schools make effective choices in efforts to find impactful ways to recognize rural and DME faculty.
医学院校在为农村和分布式医学教育(DME)教师开展表彰活动上投入了大量的时间、精力和资金。以往的文献主要关注教学的内在动机,而在文献中几乎没有指导机构表彰工作或预测哪些表彰项目或类型会最受赞赏的内容。为了更好地了解加拿大农村和DME教师如何看待不同形式的表彰,我们让加拿大所有医学院校的教师完成一项双语全国在线调查,评估他们对当前提供的奖励和表彰的看法。该调查在加拿大九个省和一个地区收到了大量英语和法语回复。我们的结果表明,带教教师看待表彰有三种不同方式;这些观点在地理和人口统计学变量中是一致的。这些“类别”或“表彰货币”包括:i)正式的机构表彰,ii)联系、成长和发展,以及iii)感激之情的象征。经济表彰也被认为很重要,但与这三个类别不同。一些带教教师确实认为支持内在动机最重要,而对另一些人来说,外在激励因素或两者的结合最受重视。研究结果将帮助医学院校做出有效的选择,努力找到有影响力的方式来表彰农村和DME教师。