School of Marine Science and Engineering, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, 210023, China.
Department of Geography and Regional Research, University of Vienna, Vienna, 1010, Austria.
J Environ Manage. 2023 Jan 1;325(Pt A):116450. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2022.116450. Epub 2022 Oct 11.
Modelling flood susceptibility is an indirect way to reduce the loss from flood disaster. Now, flood susceptibility modelling based on data driven model is state-of-the-art method such as ensemble learning and deep learning. However, the effect of deep learning coupling with ensemble learning models in flood susceptibility modelling is still unknown. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to propose three deep learning coupling with ensemble learning models by combining the deep learning (DL) with Filtered Classifier (FC), Rotation forest (RF) and Random Subspace (RSS) and explore the effect of coupling method for modelling flood susceptibility. The key step of this paper is as following: firstly, a Dingnan County which is lied in the Jiangxi Province of China is chosen as a case study, single flood event point and random sampling method was applied to generate the flood and non-flood data, respectively, then frequency ratio was utilized to analyze the relationship between each influencing factor and flood occurrence, based on the value of VIF, Spearman's correlation and One R classifier, the result show that there is no multicollinearity between each influencing factor, ten influencing factors have contribution to the flood occurrence and all of them are applied to construct the coupling model. Finally, the DL, FC-DL, RF-DL and RSS-DL were applied to produce flood susceptibility maps. Then, several statistical indexes such as area under the curve (AUC), Kappa index, accuracy (ACC), and F-measure were used to assess the accomplishment of these coupling models. For the train data, the FC-DL model acquired the highest AUC value (0.996), followed by RF-DL (0.944), RSS-DL (0.934), and DL (0.934). For the validation data, the result showed that all models have a good accomplishment (AUC>0.8). In a word, the deep learning coupling with ensemble learning models demonstrates the more reliable and excellent performance. Hence, the proposed new method will help the government for land use planning and can be applied in other area around the world.
基于数据驱动模型的洪水易感性建模是一种间接降低洪水灾害损失的方法。目前,基于数据驱动模型的洪水易感性建模是一种基于数据驱动模型的洪水易感性建模的最先进方法,如集成学习和深度学习。然而,深度学习与集成学习模型相结合在洪水易感性建模中的效果尚不清楚。因此,本文的目的是提出三种通过结合深度学习(DL)与 Filtered Classifier(FC)、Rotation forest(RF)和 Random Subspace(RSS)的深度学习与集成学习相结合的模型,并探索耦合方法对洪水易感性建模的效果。本文的关键步骤如下:首先,选择中国江西省定南县作为案例研究区,应用单点洪水事件和随机抽样方法分别生成洪水和非洪水数据,然后利用频率比分析各影响因素与洪水发生的关系,基于 VIF 值、Spearman 相关系数和 One R 分类器,结果表明各影响因素之间不存在多重共线性,十个影响因素对洪水发生有贡献,且都应用于构建耦合模型。最后,应用 DL、FC-DL、RF-DL 和 RSS-DL 生成洪水易感性图。然后,采用曲线下面积(AUC)、Kappa 指数、准确率(ACC)和 F 值等几个统计指标来评估这些耦合模型的完成情况。对于训练数据,FC-DL 模型获得了最高的 AUC 值(0.996),其次是 RF-DL(0.944)、RSS-DL(0.934)和 DL(0.934)。对于验证数据,结果表明所有模型的性能都很好(AUC>0.8)。总之,深度学习与集成学习模型的结合表现出更可靠和卓越的性能。因此,提出的新方法将有助于政府进行土地利用规划,并可应用于世界各地的其他地区。