Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School.
Department of Psychology, Lawrence University.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2022 Sep;90(9):655-669. doi: 10.1037/ccp0000763.
Rumination heightens risk for depression and anxiety, which increase substantially during adolescence. Smartphone apps offer a convenient and cost-effective means for adolescents to access mindfulness training, which may reduce rumination. Despite their increasing popularity, it is unclear which adolescents benefit from mindfulness apps.
Adolescents (n = 152) with elevated trait rumination were randomly assigned to 3 weeks of app-based mindfulness training or a mood-monitoring control. Multilevel models tested group differences in state rumination change, assessed via ecological momentary assessment. Baseline adolescent characteristics were submitted to elastic net regularization models to develop a "Personalized Advantage Index" indicating an individual's expected outcome from the mindfulness app relative to the mood-monitoring control. Finally, we translated a predictive model (developed in an external sample) for personalized recommendations of expected benefit from the mindfulness app.
Adolescents in the mindfulness app condition reported significantly greater reductions in rumination than adolescents in the control condition. Individuals predicted to have better outcomes from the mindfulness app relative to mood monitoring had significantly greater reductions in rumination if randomly assigned to the mindfulness condition. In contrast, between-condition differences in outcome were not significant for adolescents predicted to have better outcomes in the mood-monitoring condition.
Findings support the efficacy of a mindfulness app to reduce state rumination in adolescents, particularly among adolescents high in trait rumination. A predictive model is put forth, which could be used to objectively communicate expected mindfulness app outcomes to adolescents prior to engagement in app-based mindfulness training. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
反刍会增加抑郁和焦虑的风险,而青少年时期这两种情况的发生率会大幅上升。智能手机应用程序为青少年提供了一种方便且具有成本效益的方式来获得正念训练,这可能会减少反刍。尽管它们越来越受欢迎,但仍不清楚哪些青少年会从正念应用程序中受益。
有较高特质反刍倾向的青少年(n=152)被随机分配到 3 周基于应用程序的正念训练或情绪监测对照组。多层次模型测试了状态反刍变化的组间差异,通过生态瞬时评估进行评估。将青少年的基线特征提交给弹性网络正则化模型,以开发“个性化优势指数”,该指数表示个体相对于情绪监测对照组从正念应用程序中获得的预期结果。最后,我们翻译了一个预测模型(在外部样本中开发),用于个性化推荐正念应用程序的预期益处。
与对照组相比,使用正念应用程序的青少年报告的反刍显著减少。与情绪监测相比,如果随机分配到正念条件,预计从正念应用程序中获得更好结果的个体反刍减少幅度显著更大。相比之下,对于预计在情绪监测条件下表现更好的青少年,对照组之间的结果差异并不显著。
研究结果支持正念应用程序在减少青少年状态反刍方面的有效性,特别是对于特质反刍水平较高的青少年。提出了一个预测模型,可以在青少年开始基于应用程序的正念训练之前,客观地向他们传达预期的正念应用程序结果。