Reeves Paige, McConnell David, Phelan Shanon K
Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Faculty of Health, Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, Halifax, Canada.
Sociol Health Illn. 2023 Feb;45(2):317-330. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.13574. Epub 2022 Oct 28.
There is a gap between the desired outcomes of social inclusion policy and the everyday experiences of people labelled with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Despite belonging rhetorically named in social inclusion policy and practice, belonging is often absent in the lives of people labelled with intellectual and developmental disabilities and remains undertheorised in its relationship to social inclusion. In this paper, we explore the role belonging might play in narrowing the gap between how social inclusion is theorised and how it is experienced. Drawing on critical disability and feminist relational theories, we outline a relational conceptualisation of belonging and use it to 'crip' the construct of social inclusion. Exploring the synergies and tensions that surface when social inclusion and belonging are held together as discrete but interconnected constructs, we name four conceptual shifts and expansions that allow us to see social inclusion differently. Through the centring of the experiences of people labelled with intellectual and developmental disabilities, we explore the ways belonging can help to reimagine inclusion from assimilationist, static, objective and formal towards inclusion as fluid, negotiated, (inter)subjective, (in)formal and intimate.
社会包容政策的预期成果与被贴上智力和发育障碍标签的人们的日常经历之间存在差距。尽管在社会包容政策和实践中,归属感在口头上被提及,但对于被贴上智力和发育障碍标签的人们来说,归属感在他们的生活中却常常缺失,而且在其与社会包容的关系方面,理论阐释仍然不足。在本文中,我们探讨归属感在缩小社会包容的理论化与实际体验之间差距方面可能发挥的作用。借鉴批判性残疾理论和女性主义关系理论,我们勾勒出一种关于归属感的关系性概念化,并将其用于对社会包容这一概念进行“残疾视角审视”。通过探究当社会包容和归属感作为离散但相互关联的概念结合在一起时所呈现出的协同作用和紧张关系,我们提出了四个概念转变和扩展,这使我们能够以不同的视角看待社会包容。通过以被贴上智力和发育障碍标签的人们的经历为核心,我们探索归属感如何有助于将包容从同化主义、静态化、客观化和形式化的观念,重新想象为流动的、协商的、(主体间)主观的、(非)形式化的和亲密的。