IRIS Centre, School of Nursing, Midwifery & Health Systems, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Academic Affairs, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Health Expect. 2023 Feb;26(1):119-131. doi: 10.1111/hex.13603. Epub 2022 Nov 5.
Critical care bed capacity per capita in Ireland is among the lowest in Europe. The COVID-19 pandemic has put additional strain on an over-stretched healthcare system. COVID-19 community assessment hubs (CAHs) were established to prevent unnecessary admission to acute hospitals and to reduce infection spread.
The aim of this study was to assess the effectiveness and acceptability of CAHs and identify how the service might be improved or adapted for possible future use.
This was a mixed methods study, incorporating co-design with clinical stakeholders. Data collection was via an online survey and semistructured telephone interviews with staff and patients conducted between January and May 2021.
Thirty-one patients completed the survey and nine were interviewed. Twenty interviews were conducted with staff.
The findings suggest that the CAH model was successful in providing a dedicated pathway for assessing patients with COVID-19 symptoms, whilst mitigating the risk of infection. Patients were particularly positive about the timely, comprehensive and holistic care they received, as well as the accessibility of the clinics and the friendly attitudes of the staff. Staff welcomed the training and clinical protocols which contributed to their feelings of safety and competency in delivering care to this cohort of patients. They also highlighted the benefits of working in a multidisciplinary environment. Both staff and patients felt that the hubs could be repurposed for alternative use, including the treatment of chronic diseases.
This study describes staff and patients' experiences of these hubs. An unexpected outcome of this study is its demonstration of the true value of effective multidisciplinary working, not only for the staff who were deployed to this service but also for the patients in receipt of care in these hubs.
This multidisciplinary patient-centred service may provide a useful model for the delivery of other services currently delivered in hospital settings.
An earlier phase of this study involved interviews with COVID-19-positive patients on a remote monitoring programme. The data informed this phase. Several of the authors had worked in the CAHs and provided valuable input into the design of the staff and patient interviews.
爱尔兰的人均重症监护病床容量在欧洲处于较低水平。COVID-19 大流行给已经过度紧张的医疗系统带来了额外的压力。COVID-19 社区评估中心 (CAH) 的建立旨在防止不必要的急性医院入院,并减少感染传播。
本研究旨在评估 CAH 的有效性和可接受性,并确定如何改进或调整该服务,以便在未来可能的情况下使用。
这是一项混合方法研究,与临床利益相关者共同设计。数据收集是通过 2021 年 1 月至 5 月期间进行的在线调查和对工作人员和患者的半结构化电话访谈进行的。
31 名患者完成了调查,9 名患者接受了采访。对 20 名工作人员进行了 20 次访谈。
研究结果表明,CAH 模型在为 COVID-19 症状患者提供专门的评估途径方面取得了成功,同时降低了感染风险。患者对他们所接受的及时、全面和整体护理以及诊所的可及性和工作人员的友好态度特别满意。工作人员对培训和临床方案表示欢迎,这有助于他们在为这一患者群体提供护理时感到安全和有能力。他们还强调了在多学科环境中工作的好处。工作人员和患者都认为这些中心可以重新用于替代用途,包括治疗慢性疾病。
本研究描述了工作人员和患者对这些中心的体验。这项研究的一个意外结果是,它展示了有效的多学科合作的真正价值,不仅对被部署到这项服务的工作人员,而且对在这些中心接受护理的患者也是如此。
这种多学科以患者为中心的服务可能为在医院环境中提供的其他服务提供了有用的模式。
本研究的早期阶段涉及对远程监测计划中 COVID-19 阳性患者的访谈。这些数据为这一阶段提供了信息。几位作者曾在 CAH 工作,并为工作人员和患者访谈的设计提供了宝贵的意见。