York University, Canada.
University of Calgary, Canada.
Soc Sci Res. 2022 Nov;108:102750. doi: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2022.102750. Epub 2022 Jun 10.
Extant theory suggests that crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic may change people's trust in others. A crisis-to-solidarity model suggests that people become more trusting, while a crisis-to-negative experience theory suggests that people lose trust, and a stability perspective predicts that social trust will largely remain unchanged. We argue that, when a crisis occurs, trust is likely to fall into distinct trajectories of change that will conform to these different perspectives, and placement into contrasting trajectories of change will be predicated on socioeconomic position. To test our argument, we use data from multiple waves of Canadian national surveys conducted from September 2019 to February 2021 and examine how two major forms of social trust-generalized trust and neighborhood trust-changed during the COVID-19 pandemic. A longitudinal latent class analysis (LLCA) shows increasing, decreasing, and stable trajectories of trust, which conform to each of the proposed patterns. We further show that individuals' baseline socioeconomic position is a strong indicator of the placement in these trajectories. Both forms of trust increased among individuals with higher socioeconomic positions while decreased among individuals with lower socioeconomic positions. This research contributes to the literature on the social context of trust by reconciling contrasting views of the consequences of crises for trust, and also in showing that the segmentation of changes in trust are proscribed by structures of social stratification.
现有理论表明,新冠疫情等危机可能会改变人们对他人的信任。危机-团结模型表明,人们会变得更加信任,而危机-负面经验理论表明,人们会失去信任,稳定观点则预测社会信任将基本保持不变。我们认为,当危机发生时,信任可能会沿着符合这些不同观点的不同变化轨迹发生变化,而进入不同变化轨迹的位置将取决于社会经济地位。为了验证我们的观点,我们使用了 2019 年 9 月至 2021 年 2 月期间进行的多次加拿大全国调查的多波数据,并研究了在新冠疫情期间两种主要形式的社会信任——普遍信任和邻里信任是如何变化的。纵向潜在类别分析(LLCA)显示,信任存在增加、减少和稳定的轨迹,这与每个提出的模式一致。我们进一步表明,个体的基线社会经济地位是这些轨迹中位置的一个强有力指标。在社会经济地位较高的个体中,这两种形式的信任都有所增加,而在社会经济地位较低的个体中则有所减少。这项研究通过调和对危机对信任的后果的不同观点,为信任的社会背景文献做出了贡献,也表明信任变化的细分是由社会分层结构规定的。