Manuskiatti Woraphong, Yan Chadakan, Gulfan Ma Christina Banate, Techapichetvanich Thanya, Wanitphakdeedecha Rungsima
Department of Dermatology, Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand.
Lasers Surg Med. 2022 Dec;54(10):1245-1250. doi: 10.1002/lsm.23615. Epub 2022 Nov 8.
While combined laser and topical treatments are currently a common approach to melasma treatment, data on the efficacy and safety of this combined therapy remain scarce, with studies showing varied results.
To compare the efficacy and safety of hydroquinone (HQ) cream alone versus HQ cream combined with 755-nm picosecond (PS) laser in the treatment of melasma.
Twenty subjects presenting with mixed-type melasma were enrolled in the study. All patients were instructed to apply 2% HQ cream to both sides of the face for 4 weeks. Randomly assigned hemifaces of all patients thereafter received 5 biweekly PS laser treatments. Objective (measurement of average melanin content and melanin index) and subjective (grading of modified melasma area and severity index [mMASI] score and global percentage of pigment clearance) assessments of melasma clearance, and occurrence of adverse effects were evaluated at 1-, 3-, and 6-months after the final laser treatment.
mMASI scores were significantly improved from baseline for both sides (p = 0.006 HQ alone, p < 0.001 HQ + PS laser), with no statistically significant difference when comparing HQ alone versus HQ + PS laser. Objective assessments (measurements of average melanin content and melanin index) of melasma clearance corresponded to the clinical evaluation using mMASI score. Mild postinflammatory hyperpigmentation was observed in 15% of the patients on the laser-treated side, while no adverse effects were reported on the HQ monotherapy side.
Adjunctive treatment with a 755-nm PS laser does not provide additional benefit to topical HQ in the treatment of melasma. ClinicalTrail.gov PRS. number: NCT04597203.
虽然激光和局部治疗联合使用目前是黄褐斑治疗的常用方法,但关于这种联合治疗的疗效和安全性的数据仍然很少,研究结果各不相同。
比较单独使用氢醌(HQ)乳膏与HQ乳膏联合755纳米皮秒(PS)激光治疗黄褐斑的疗效和安全性。
20名混合型黄褐斑患者参与了该研究。所有患者均被指示在面部两侧涂抹2%的HQ乳膏,持续4周。此后,所有患者随机分配的半侧面部每两周接受5次PS激光治疗。在最后一次激光治疗后的1个月、3个月和6个月,评估黄褐斑清除的客观指标(平均黑色素含量和黑色素指数的测量)和主观指标(改良黄褐斑面积和严重程度指数[mMASI]评分及色素清除总体百分比的分级),以及不良反应的发生情况。
两侧的mMASI评分均较基线有显著改善(单独使用HQ时p = 0.006,HQ + PS激光时p < 0.001),单独使用HQ与HQ + PS激光相比无统计学显著差异。黄褐斑清除的客观评估(平均黑色素含量和黑色素指数的测量)与使用mMASI评分的临床评估结果一致。激光治疗侧15%的患者出现轻度炎症后色素沉着,而HQ单一疗法侧未报告不良反应。
在黄褐斑治疗中,755纳米PS激光辅助治疗对局部使用HQ并无额外益处。ClinicalTrail.gov注册号:NCT04597203。