School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland; Insight Centre for Data Analytics, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Int J Med Inform. 2023 Jan;169:104911. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2022.104911. Epub 2022 Nov 2.
Monitoring systems have been developed during the COVID-19 pandemic enabling clinicians to remotely monitor physiological measures including pulse oxygen saturation (SpO), heart rate (HR), and breathlessness in patients after discharge from hospital. These data may be leveraged to understand how symptoms vary over time in COVID-19 patients. There is also potential to use remote monitoring systems to predict clinical deterioration allowing early identification of patients in need of intervention.
A remote monitoring system was used to monitor 209 patients diagnosed with COVID-19 in the period following hospital discharge. This system consisted of a patient-facing app paired with a Bluetooth-enabled pulse oximeter (measuring SpO and HR) linked to a secure portal where data were available for clinical review. Breathlessness score was entered manually to the app. Clinical teams were alerted automatically when SpO < 94 %. In this study, data recorded during the initial ten days of monitoring were retrospectively examined, and a random forest model was developed to predict SpO < 94 % on a given day using SpO and HR data from the two previous days and day of discharge.
Over the 10-day monitoring period, mean SpO and HR increased significantly, while breathlessness decreased. The coefficient of variation in SpO, HR and breathlessness also decreased over the monitoring period. The model predicted SpO alerts (SpO < 94 %) with a mean cross-validated. sensitivity of 66 ± 18.57 %, specificity of 88.31 ± 10.97 % and area under the receiver operating characteristic of 0.80 ± 0.11. Patient age and sex were not significantly associated with the occurrence of asymptomatic SpO alerts.
Results indicate that SpO alerts (SpO < 94 %) on a given day can be predicted using SpO and heart rate data captured on the two preceding days via remote monitoring. The methods presented may help early identification of patients with COVID-19 at risk of clinical deterioration using remote monitoring.
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,已经开发了监测系统,使临床医生能够远程监测生理指标,包括出院后患者的脉搏血氧饱和度(SpO2)、心率(HR)和呼吸困难。这些数据可用于了解 COVID-19 患者的症状随时间的变化。远程监测系统还具有预测临床恶化的潜力,从而能够早期识别需要干预的患者。
使用远程监测系统监测了 209 名出院后 COVID-19 患者。该系统由面向患者的应用程序和一个蓝牙连接的脉搏血氧仪(测量 SpO2 和 HR)组成,连接到一个安全门户,其中可获取数据供临床审查。呼吸困难评分手动输入到应用程序中。当 SpO2<94%时,临床团队会自动收到警报。在本研究中,回顾性检查了监测的最初十天记录的数据,并开发了一个随机森林模型,使用前两天和出院当天的 SpO2 和 HR 数据预测给定日期的 SpO2<94%。
在 10 天的监测期间,平均 SpO2 和 HR 显著增加,而呼吸困难减轻。监测期间,SpO2、HR 和呼吸困难的变异系数也降低。该模型预测 SpO 警报(SpO2<94%)的平均交叉验证敏感性为 66±18.57%,特异性为 88.31±10.97%,接受者操作特征曲线下面积为 0.80±0.11。患者年龄和性别与无症状 SpO 警报的发生无显著相关性。
结果表明,通过远程监测,可以使用前两天捕获的 SpO2 和心率数据预测给定日期的 SpO 警报(SpO2<94%)。所提出的方法可能有助于使用远程监测早期识别 COVID-19 患者的临床恶化风险。