School of Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Ottawa, Ottawa K1G 5Z3, Canada.
Bruyère Research Institute, Ottawa K1N 5C8, Canada.
Int Health. 2023 Jul 4;15(4):462-473. doi: 10.1093/inthealth/ihac070.
This systematic review assesses participatory approaches to motivating positive change among health workers in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The mistreatment of clients at health centres has been extensively documented, causing stress among clients, health complications and even avoidance of health centres altogether. Health workers, too, face challenges, including medicine shortages, task shifting, inadequate training and a lack of managerial support. Solutions are urgently needed to realise global commitments to quality primary healthcare, country ownership and universal health coverage. This review searched 1243 titles and abstracts, of which 32 were extracted for full text review using a published critical assessment tool. Eight papers were retained for final review, all using a single methodology, 'Health Workers for Change' (HWFC). The intervention was adapted to diverse geographical and health settings. Nine indicators from the included studies were assessed, eliciting many common findings and documenting an overall positive impact of the HWFC approach. Health workers acknowledged their negative behaviour towards clients, often as a way of coping with their own unmet needs. In most settings they developed action plans to address these issues. Recommendations are made on mainstreaming HWFC into health systems in LMICs and its potential application to alleviating stress and burnout from COVID-19.
本系统评价评估了参与式方法在激励中低收入国家(LMICs)卫生工作者积极变革方面的作用。医疗机构工作人员虐待患者的现象屡见不鲜,不仅给患者带来压力,还会导致医疗并发症,甚至使患者完全回避医疗机构。卫生工作者也面临着各种挑战,包括药品短缺、工作任务转移、培训不足以及缺乏管理层支持。为了实现全球对优质初级卫生保健、国家自主权和全民健康覆盖的承诺,迫切需要寻找解决方案。本研究共检索到 1243 篇标题和摘要,其中 32 篇使用已发表的关键评估工具进行全文审查。最终保留了 8 篇论文进行最终审查,均采用单一方法“卫生工作者变革”(HWFC)。该干预措施适用于不同的地理和卫生环境。纳入研究的 9 项指标进行了评估,得出了许多共同的发现,并记录了 HWFC 方法的总体积极影响。卫生工作者承认他们对患者的负面行为,这通常是他们应对自身未满足需求的一种方式。在大多数情况下,他们制定了行动计划来解决这些问题。建议将 HWFC 纳入 LMIC 国家的卫生系统,并探讨其在缓解 COVID-19 带来的压力和倦怠方面的潜在应用。