Department of Values, Technology and Innovation/Economics of Technology and Innovation, Delft University of Technology, Jaffalaan 5, 2628 BX, Delft, The Netherlands.
Department of Values, Technology and Innovation/Ethics and Philosophy of Technology, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands.
Sci Eng Ethics. 2022 Nov 10;28(6):55. doi: 10.1007/s11948-022-00403-3.
In this paper, we take inspiration from original institutional economics (OIE) as an approach to study value change within the highly complex assembly of sociotechnical transformations that make up the energy transition. OIE is examined here as a suitable perspective, as it combines Dewey's pragmatist philosophy and a methodological interactionist perspective on value change, behavior and institutions, with technology figuring as a transformational factor. This combination overcomes conceptual and methodological shortcomings of alternative accounts of values. We will present the contours of an OIE based conceptual framework connecting nature, humans, technology, the economic process, society, culture and institutions and habits, valuation and behavior. We illustrate how to use this framework to examine and understand how environmental, ecologic, safety, economic, and social concerns about the energy transition are (re)framed as (new) values in the belief systems and habits of individuals and groups. Moreover, we will explore how that may give rise to collective action, via the institutionalization of such revised values in the procedures, arrangements, norms and incentives guiding transactions. As such, this approach allows us in a fine-grained manner to conceptually and theoretically understand the way in which values change in the energy-transition, as a complex interaction of technology development and social relations.
在本文中,我们从原始制度经济学(OIE)中汲取灵感,将其作为一种方法来研究构成能源转型的高度复杂的社会技术变革组合内的价值变化。OIE 在这里被视为一种合适的视角,因为它将杜威的实用主义哲学和关于价值变化、行为和制度的方法论互动主义观点与作为变革因素的技术结合在一起。这种结合克服了替代价值观念的概念和方法上的不足。我们将提出一个基于 OIE 的概念框架的轮廓,该框架将自然、人类、技术、经济过程、社会、文化和制度以及习惯、价值观和行为联系起来。我们将说明如何使用这个框架来研究和理解能源转型的环境、生态、安全、经济和社会问题是如何在个人和群体的信仰体系和习惯中被重新定义为(新)价值观的。此外,我们将探讨这种情况如何通过在指导交易的程序、安排、规范和激励中使这些经过修订的价值观制度化而引发集体行动。因此,这种方法使我们能够以精细的方式从概念和理论上理解能源转型中价值变化的方式,即技术发展和社会关系的复杂相互作用。