School of Public Administration, Central South University, Changsha 410083, China.
Center for Social Stability Risk Assessment, Central South University, Changsha 410083, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Oct 22;19(21):13761. doi: 10.3390/ijerph192113761.
In the process of continuously promoting safety management, major road accidents have become a key obstacle to improving overall road safety. The analysis of the overall road accidents hides the characteristics and laws of major road accidents. To clarify the causes of major road accidents, an analysis framework of "individual-vehicle-environment-management" is presented based on a literature review. Considering the interaction of the above variables, the fuzz-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) was used to explore the generating paths of major road accidents based on 42 road accidents. The work shows that: (1) Major road accidents are caused due to the interactive coupling of "individual-vehicle-environment-management" elements. Major road accidents can occur with normal driving behaviors or sufficient response and rescue capabilities. (2) General road accidents and relatively major road accidents are more likely to occur in the presence of driving behavior errors, favorable road facilities, and sufficient response and rescue capabilities. Moreover, major road accidents are more likely to occur due to large vehicles with adverse vehicle performances. (3) There are three path modes and five condition configurations in major road accidents, namely individual-vehicle-management induced, individual-vehicle-environment induced, and vehicle induced mode. This work enriches the accident causation mode from a new configuration perspective and explains which variable combinations lead to the occurrence of major road accidents. Clarification of the differences between general accidents and major accidents will help to accurately predict and restrain the development of major road accidents.
在不断推进安全管理的过程中,重大道路交通事故已成为提升整体道路安全水平的关键阻碍。整体道路交通事故分析掩盖了重大道路交通事故的特点和规律。为了厘清重大道路交通事故的成因,本文在文献综述的基础上,构建了“人-车-环境-管理”的分析框架。考虑到上述变量的交互作用,运用模糊集定性比较分析(fsQCA)方法,基于 42 起道路交通事故,探讨了重大道路交通事故的生成路径。结果表明:(1)“人-车-环境-管理”要素的交互耦合导致了重大道路交通事故的发生,正常驾驶行为或充足的响应和救援能力也可能导致重大道路交通事故的发生。(2)一般道路事故和相对重大道路事故更可能发生在存在驾驶行为错误、有利的道路设施和充足的响应和救援能力的情况下,此外,由于车辆性能不佳,大型车辆更有可能发生重大道路事故。(3)重大道路事故存在个体-车辆-管理诱发、个体-车辆-环境诱发和车辆诱发三种路径模式和五种条件组态。本研究从新的配置角度丰富了事故致因模式,解释了哪些变量组合会导致重大道路交通事故的发生。厘清一般事故和重大事故之间的差异,有助于准确预测和遏制重大道路交通事故的发展。