Winburn Allysha Powanda, Miller Wolf Katherine A, Marten Meredith G
The University of West Florida Department of Anthropology, USA.
Forensic Sci Int Synerg. 2022 Oct 28;5:100289. doi: 10.1016/j.fsisyn.2022.100289. eCollection 2022.
Human societies create and maintain structures in which individuals and groups experience varying degrees of inequity and suffering that may be skeletally and dentally embodied. It is necessary to foreground these social and structural impacts for forensic anthropologists to eschew biologically deterministic interpretations of human variation and overly individualistic interpretations of health and disease. We thus propose a 'Structural Vulnerability Profile' (SVP), akin to the Structural Vulnerability Assessment Tool of medical anthropology [1], to be considered along with the traditional 'biological' profile estimated by forensic anthropologists. Assembling an SVP would involve examining and assessing skeletal/dental biomarkers indicative of embodied social inequity-the lived experiences of social marginalization that can get 'under the skin' to leave hard-tissue traces. Shifting our emphasis from presumably hereditary variation to focus on embodied social marginalization, the SVP will allow forensic anthropologists to sensitively reconstruct the lived experiences of the people we examine.
人类社会创造并维持着这样的结构,在其中个体和群体经历着不同程度的不平等和苦难,这些不平等和苦难可能会体现在骨骼和牙齿上。对于法医人类学家来说,必须突出这些社会和结构影响,以避免对人类变异进行生物学决定论的解释,以及对健康和疾病进行过度个人主义的解释。因此,我们提出一个“结构脆弱性概况”(SVP),类似于医学人类学的结构脆弱性评估工具[1],以便与法医人类学家估计的传统“生物学”概况一同考虑。构建一个SVP将涉及检查和评估指示体现社会不平等的骨骼/牙齿生物标志物——社会边缘化的生活经历,这些经历可以“深入皮肤”留下硬组织痕迹。将我们的重点从推测的遗传变异转移到关注体现的社会边缘化,SVP将使法医人类学家能够敏感地重建我们所研究人群的生活经历。