Appel Nicollette S, Edgar Heather J H, Berry Shamsi Daneshvari, Hunley Keith
Department of Anthropology, University of New Mexico, USA.
Office of the Medical Investigator, University of New Mexico, USA.
Forensic Sci Int Synerg. 2023 Jun 8;7:100338. doi: 10.1016/j.fsisyn.2023.100338. eCollection 2023.
Researchers use public records from deceased individuals to identify trends in manners and causes of death. Errors in the description of race and ethnicity can affect the inferences researchers draw, adversely impacting public health policies designed to eliminate health inequity. Using the New Mexico Decedent Image Database, we examine: 1) the accuracy of death investigator descriptions of race and ethnicity by comparing their reports to those from next of kin (NOK), 2) the impact of decedent age and sex on disagreement between death investigators and NOK, and 3) the relationship between investigators' descriptions of decedent race and ethnicity and cause and manner of death from forensic pathologists (n = 1813). Results demonstrate that investigators frequently describe race and ethnicity incorrectly for Hispanic/Latino decedents, especially regarding homicide manner of death and injury and substance abuse causes of death. Inaccuracies may cause biased misperceptions of violence within specific communities and affect investigative processes.
研究人员利用已故个体的公共记录来确定死亡方式和原因的趋势。种族和族裔描述中的错误会影响研究人员得出的推论,对旨在消除健康不平等的公共卫生政策产生不利影响。利用新墨西哥州死者图像数据库,我们研究了:1)通过将死亡调查员的报告与近亲(NOK)的报告进行比较,来检验死亡调查员对种族和族裔描述的准确性;2)死者年龄和性别对死亡调查员与近亲之间分歧的影响;3)调查员对死者种族和族裔的描述与法医病理学家确定的死亡原因和方式之间的关系(n = 1813)。结果表明,调查员经常错误地描述西班牙裔/拉丁裔死者的种族和族裔,尤其是在涉及杀人死亡方式以及伤害和药物滥用导致的死亡原因方面。不准确的描述可能会导致对特定社区内暴力行为产生有偏差的误解,并影响调查过程。