Maeda Wakae, Hirakawa Yoshihisa, Muraya Tsukasa, Miura Hisayuki
Faculty of Nursing, Chukyo Gakuin University, Japan.
Department of Public Health and Health Systems, Nagoya University Graduate School of Medicine, Japan.
J Rural Med. 2022 Oct;17(4):279-282. doi: 10.2185/jrm.2021-063. Epub 2022 Oct 22.
This pilot study aimed to examine the content of Japanese newspaper editorials concerning the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic and its change over time using text mining analysis. The authors analyzed qualitative data from the editorials of five national and 12 regional newspapers on April 7 and 8, 2020 (first state of emergency) and January 8, 2021 (second state of emergency). All analyses were conducted using KH Coder version 3. The co-occurrence network showed a low level of content diversity and a high degree of politicization in the COVID-19 news coverage. The top five high frequency words from the newspapers were "infection", "declaration", "healthcare", "government", and "emergency" at the first state of emergency, and were "declaration", "measures", "government", and "restaurant" at the second one. The results suggest a lack of detailed information and recommendations concerning the public health challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic in Japanese newspaper editorials, even one year after the first wave of the pandemic. This study provides a data-driven foundation for the effectiveness of newspapers in COVID-19 public health communications. The extent to which the quantity and quality of information from newly emerging communication channels, such as social media, influences public understanding of public health measures remains to be established.
这项试点研究旨在通过文本挖掘分析,审视日本报纸社论中有关2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行的内容及其随时间的变化。作者分析了五家全国性报纸和12家地区性报纸在2020年4月7日和8日(首次紧急状态)以及2021年1月8日(第二次紧急状态)社论中的定性数据。所有分析均使用KH Coder 3版本进行。共现网络显示,COVID-19新闻报道的内容多样性水平较低,政治化程度较高。在首次紧急状态下,报纸上出现频率最高的五个词是“感染”“声明”“医疗保健”“政府”和“紧急情况”,在第二次紧急状态下则是“声明”“措施”“政府”和“餐馆”。结果表明,即使在大流行第一波爆发一年后,日本报纸社论中仍缺乏有关COVID-19大流行公共卫生挑战的详细信息和建议。本研究为报纸在COVID-19公共卫生传播中的有效性提供了数据驱动的基础。新兴传播渠道(如社交媒体)提供的信息数量和质量在多大程度上影响公众对公共卫生措施的理解,仍有待确定。