Jeitler Michael, Storz Maximilian Andreas, Steckhan Nico, Matthiae Dorothea, Dressler Justina, Hanslian Etienne, Koppold Daniela A, Kandil Farid I, Michalsen Andreas, Kessler Christian S
Institute of Social Medicine, Epidemiology and Health Economics, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Corporate Member of Freie Universität Berlin and Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, 10117 Berlin, Germany.
Department for Complementary and Integrative Medicine, Immanuel Hospital Berlin, 14109 Berlin, Germany.
Foods. 2022 Dec 14;11(24):4033. doi: 10.3390/foods11244033.
Plant-based diets are associated with numerous health benefits but also bear risks of micronutrient deficiencies if inadequately planned. The risk of nutrient deficiencies can be reliably reduced by supplementation but requires risk-awareness. We distributed a paper-and-pencil questionnaire to = 902 healthcare professionals attending a congress on plant-based nutrition (VegMed 2018, Berlin). On the day of the survey (21 April 2018), = 475 questionnaires were returned and analyzed descriptively. Of the = 213 strict vegan participants, 2% ( = 5) took no supplements at all. All supplementing vegans reported taking vitamin B12. Almost three-quarters of vegans (73%, = 152) took vitamin D, and 22% ( = 45) reported taking omega-3 fatty acids. Iron was supplemented by 13% ( = 28), iodine by 12% ( = 25), calcium by 11% ( = 22), zinc by 7% ( = 14), magnesium by 5% ( = 11), and selenium by 4% ( = 9). For 11%, a supplement other than vitamin B12 was subjectively most important. Nearly 50% had their vitamin B12 levels laboratory tested at least once a year; nearly one-quarter reported testing every two years, and another one-quarter rarely or never. Participants following a vegan diet were better informed about institutional recommendations of the German Nutrition Society and the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics for vegan diets than participants following vegetarian or omnivorous diets. Vegan nutrition in pregnancy/lactation period and childhood was considered most appropriate by vegans. Despite a high awareness of potential health risks associated with vitamin B12 deficiency on a strict vegan diet and a comprehensive understanding of the official dietary recommendations of nutrition societies, use of supplements and performance of regular laboratory tests were only moderate among vegan healthcare professionals. Considering the paramount importance of adequate supplementation of critical nutrients to avoid nutrient deficiencies, scientific and public discourse should be further facilitated. Further investigation of the supplementation behavior of vegan health professionals could be of particular interest, as a possible correlation with the quality of their own nutrition counseling is not inconceivable.
植物性饮食有诸多健康益处,但如果规划不当也有微量营养素缺乏的风险。通过补充剂可可靠地降低营养素缺乏风险,但需要有风险意识。我们向参加植物性营养大会(2018年素食医学大会,柏林)的902名医疗保健专业人员发放了纸质问卷。在调查当天(2018年4月21日),回收了475份问卷并进行描述性分析。在213名严格素食参与者中,2%(即5人)完全不服用补充剂。所有服用补充剂的素食者都报告服用维生素B12。近四分之三的素食者(73%,即152人)服用维生素D,22%(即45人)报告服用ω-3脂肪酸。13%(即28人)补充铁,12%(即25人)补充碘,11%(即22人)补充钙,7%(即14人)补充锌,5%(即11人)补充镁,4%(即9人)补充硒。11%的人认为除维生素B12外的其他补充剂在主观上最为重要。近50%的人每年至少进行一次维生素B12水平的实验室检测;近四分之一的人报告每两年检测一次,另有四分之一的人很少或从不检测。与遵循素食或杂食饮食的参与者相比,遵循纯素饮食的参与者更了解德国营养学会和营养与饮食学会针对纯素饮食的机构建议。素食者认为孕期/哺乳期和儿童期的纯素营养最为合适。尽管严格的纯素饮食者对维生素B12缺乏相关的潜在健康风险有较高认识,且对营养学会的官方饮食建议有全面了解,但在素食医疗保健专业人员中,补充剂的使用和定期实验室检测的执行情况仅处于中等水平。鉴于充分补充关键营养素以避免营养素缺乏至关重要,应进一步促进科学和公众讨论。对素食健康专业人员补充行为的进一步调查可能会特别有意义,因为与他们自身营养咨询质量之间存在可能的关联并非不可想象。