Faculty of Social Work and Children's Hospital Research Institute of Manitoba, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB R3T 2N2, Canada.
Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB R3E 0W2, Canada.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Dec 8;19(24):16481. doi: 10.3390/ijerph192416481.
Child maltreatment is a global public health and child rights crisis made worse by the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. While understanding the breadth of the child maltreatment crisis is foundational to informing prevention and response efforts, determining accurate estimates of child maltreatment remains challenging. Alternative informants (parents, caregivers, a Person Most Knowledgeable-PMK) are often tasked with reporting on children's maltreatment experiences in surveys to mitigate concerns associated with reporting child maltreatment. The overall purpose of this study was to examine child maltreatment reporting practices in surveys by PMKs for children and youth. The research question is: "What is the nature of the evidence of child maltreatment reporting practices in general population surveys by PMKs for children and youth?" A rapid scoping review was conducted to achieve the study's purpose. A search strategy was conducted in nine databases (e.g., MEDLINE, EBSCO, Scopus, Global Health, ProQuest). The findings from this review indicate that most studies involved PMK informants (i.e., maternal caregivers), included representative samples from primarily Western contexts, and utilized validated measures to assess child maltreatment. Half of the studies assessed involved multi-informant reports, including the PMKs and child/youth. Overall, the congruence between PMK-reported and child/youth-reported child maltreatment experiences was low-to-fair/moderate, and children/youth reported more maltreatment than the PMKs.
儿童虐待是全球公共卫生和儿童权利危机,而持续的 COVID-19 大流行使这一危机更加恶化。虽然了解儿童虐待危机的广泛程度是为预防和应对工作提供信息的基础,但确定儿童虐待的准确估计仍然具有挑战性。替代报告人(父母、照顾者、最了解情况的人-PMK)通常负责在调查中报告儿童的虐待经历,以减轻与报告儿童虐待有关的担忧。本研究的总体目的是检查 PMK 对儿童和青年进行调查中的儿童虐待报告做法。研究问题是:“PMK 对儿童和青年进行的一般人群调查中,儿童虐待报告做法的证据性质如何?”进行了快速范围审查以实现研究目的。在九个数据库(例如 MEDLINE、EBSCO、Scopus、全球健康、ProQuest)中进行了搜索策略。这项审查的结果表明,大多数研究涉及 PMK 报告人(即产妇照顾者),包括主要来自西方背景的代表性样本,并使用经过验证的措施来评估儿童虐待。有一半的研究评估涉及多报告人报告,包括 PMK 和儿童/青年。总体而言,PMK 报告的和儿童/青年报告的儿童虐待经历之间的一致性较低到中等/适度,而且儿童/青年报告的虐待比 PMK 多。