Taylor Charlotte, Kidgell Jasmin
School of Media, Arts & Humanities, University of Sussex, UK.
Discourse Context Media. 2021 Jun;41:100503. doi: 10.1016/j.dcm.2021.100503. Epub 2021 May 7.
The use of metaphor in framing COVID-19 has already attracted considerable attention in both academic and public debate and we have seen extensive discussion of how this pandemic might be compared to past events, such as the so-called 'Spanish flu' of the 1910s. In this paper, we draw these two strands of metaphoric framing and historical comparison together by identifying the metaphorical framings of past influenza pandemics in media and political discourse in the UK over an extended period (1890-2009). The findings show remarkable continuity in the choice and proportion of conceptual metaphor across very different sociohistorical contexts. However, this does not correspond to entrenchment of the metaphors which continue to be creative and elaborated in many cases. In terms of variation over time, the analysis shows shifts in framing with greater focus on societal effects and reactions to influenza in later periods while the agency of the virus is reduced.
在构建对新冠疫情的认知过程中,隐喻的运用在学术和公众辩论中都已引起了相当大的关注,而且我们已经看到了大量关于如何将这场大流行病与过去事件进行比较的讨论,比如20世纪10年代所谓的“西班牙流感”。在本文中,我们通过确定英国在较长时期(1890 - 2009年)内媒体和政治话语中过去流感大流行的隐喻框架,将隐喻框架和历史比较这两条线索结合起来。研究结果表明,在截然不同的社会历史背景下,概念隐喻的选择和比例具有显著的连续性。然而,这并不意味着隐喻会一成不变,在很多情况下,这些隐喻仍具有创造性并得到进一步阐释。就随时间的变化而言,分析表明框架发生了转变,后期更加关注流感对社会的影响和反应,而病毒的作用则被弱化。