Matei Raluca, Phillips Keith
Institute of Education, Social and Life Sciences, University of Chichester, Chichester, UK.
Centre for Music Performance Research, Royal Northern College of Music, Manchester, UK.
Health Promot Int. 2023 Feb 1;38(1). doi: 10.1093/heapro/daac179.
Although health education programmes have been implemented in higher music education (HME) and their evaluations published in peer-reviewed journals, guidelines as to what ought to be included in these programmes are still missing. This study aimed to document expert discussions on the content of an ideal health education curriculum for HME students in the UK, integrating critical thinking. Four interdisciplinary workshops were conducted, where 67 experts in relevant fields took part, and were asked to discuss four lists of topics and concepts created based on literature reviews (cognitive biases, logical fallacies, critical appraisal tools and health topics). Only the list on health topics is relevant here. Notes taken by the participants and ourselves were thematically analysed. Four themes were identified, two of which are reported in this paper: (i) The health education curriculum and (ii) A settings-based approach to health. Part I of this project (published elsewhere) is focussed on the critical thinking content of health education for conservatoire students. The present paper focusses on the ideal health education curriculum and its implications for the wider context of health promotion.
尽管健康教育项目已在高等音乐教育(HME)中实施,且其评估结果已发表在同行评审期刊上,但关于这些项目应包含哪些内容的指导方针仍然缺失。本研究旨在记录英国高等音乐教育学生理想健康教育课程内容的专家讨论,其中融入批判性思维。举办了四次跨学科研讨会,67位相关领域的专家参与其中,并要求他们讨论基于文献综述创建的四个主题和概念列表(认知偏差、逻辑谬误、批判性评估工具和健康主题)。在此仅健康主题列表相关。对参与者和我们自己所做的笔记进行了主题分析。确定了四个主题,本文报告其中两个:(i)健康教育课程和(ii)基于环境的健康方法。该项目的第一部分(发表于其他地方)聚焦于音乐学院学生健康教育的批判性思维内容。本文聚焦于理想的健康教育课程及其对更广泛健康促进背景的影响。