Sullivan Nathaniel A T, Smit Johannes A, Lachkar Nadia, Logjes Robrecht J H, Kruisinga Frea H, Reinert Siegmar, Persson Martin, Davies Gareth, Breugem Corstiaan C
Department of Plastic Surgery, Amsterdam UMC, Location University of Amsterdam, Emma Childrens Hospital, Meibergdreef 9, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Amsterdam Reproduction and Development, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Eur J Pediatr. 2023 Mar;182(3):1271-1280. doi: 10.1007/s00431-022-04781-5. Epub 2023 Jan 12.
The goal of this study was to explore the availability of diagnostic and treatment options for managing upper airway obstruction (UAO) in infants with Robin Sequence (RS) in Europe. Countries were divided in lower- (LHECs, i.e., PPP per capita < $4000) and higher-health expenditure countries (HHECs, i.e., PPP per capita ≥ $4000). An online survey was sent to European healthcare professionals who treat RS. The survey was designed to determine the availability of diagnostic tools such as arterial blood gas analysis (ABG), pulse oximetry, CO2 analysis, polysomnography (PSG), and sleep questionnaires, as well as to identify the used treatment options in a specific center. Responses were received from professionals of 85 centers, originating from 31 different countries. It was equally challenging to provide care for infants with RS in both LHECs and HHECs (3.67/10 versus 2.65/10, p = 0.45). Furthermore, in the LHECs, there was less access to ABG (85% versus 98%, p = 0.03), CO2 analysis (45% versus 70%, p = 0.03), and PSG (54% versus 93%, p < 0.01). There were no significant differences in the accessibility concerning pulse oximetry, sleep questionnaires, home saturation monitoring, nasopharyngeal tubes, Tuebingen plates, and mandibular distraction. Conclusion: This study demonstrates a large difference in available care for infants with RS throughout Europe. LHECs have less access to diagnostic tools in RS when compared to HHECs. There is, however, no difference in the availability of treatment modalities between LHECs and HHECs. What is Known: • Patients with Robin sequence (RS) require complex and multidisciplinary care. They can present with moderate to severe upper airway obstruction (UAO). There exists a large variety in the use of diagnostics for both UAO treatment indications and evaluations. In most cases, conservative management of UAO in RS is sufficient. Patients with UAO that persist despite conservative management ultimately need surgical intervention. To determine which intervention is best suitable for the individual RS patient, the level of UAO needs to be determined through diagnostic testing. • There is a substantial variation among institutions across Europe for both diagnostics and treatment options in UAO. A standardized, internationally accepted protocol for the assessment and management of UAO in RS could guide healthcare professionals in the timing of assessment and indications to prevent escalation of UAO. Creating such a protocol might be a challenge, as there are large financial differences between countries in Europe (e.g., health expenditure per capita in purchasing power parity in international dollars ranges from $600 to over $8500). What is New: • There is a substantial variation in the availability of objective diagnostic tools between European countries. Arterial blood gas analysis, CO2 analysis and polysomnography are not equally accessible for lower-healthcare expenditure countries (LHECs) compared to higher-healthcare expenditure countries (HHECs). These differences are not only limited to availability; there is also a difference in quality of these diagnostic tools. Surprisingly, there is no difference in access to treatment tools between LHECs and HHECs. • There is national heterogeneity in access to tools for diagnosis and treatment of RS, which suggests centralization of health care, showing that specialized care is only available in tertiary centers. By centralization of care for RS infants, diagnostics and treatment can be optimized in the best possible way to create a uniform European protocol and ultimately equal care across Europe. Learning what is necessary for adequate monitoring could lead to better allocation of resources, which is especially important in a low-resource setting.
本研究的目的是探讨欧洲患有罗宾序列征(RS)的婴儿上气道梗阻(UAO)的诊断和治疗选择的可及性。国家被分为低卫生支出国家(LHECs,即人均购买力平价<4000美元)和高卫生支出国家(HHECs,即人均购买力平价≥4000美元)。向治疗RS的欧洲医疗保健专业人员发送了一项在线调查。该调查旨在确定诊断工具的可及性,如动脉血气分析(ABG)、脉搏血氧饱和度测定、二氧化碳分析、多导睡眠图(PSG)和睡眠问卷,以及确定特定中心所采用的治疗选择。收到了来自31个不同国家的85个中心的专业人员的回复。在LHECs和HHECs中为患有RS的婴儿提供护理同样具有挑战性(分别为3.67/10和2.65/10,p = 0.45)。此外,在LHECs中,获得ABG(85%对98%,p = 0.03)、二氧化碳分析(45%对70%,p = 0.03)和PSG(54%对93%,p < 0.01)的机会较少。在脉搏血氧饱和度测定、睡眠问卷、家庭饱和度监测、鼻咽管、图宾根板和下颌骨牵张方面的可及性没有显著差异。结论:本研究表明欧洲各地为患有RS的婴儿提供的护理存在很大差异。与HHECs相比,LHECs获得RS诊断工具的机会较少。然而,LHECs和HHECs在治疗方式的可及性方面没有差异。已知信息:• 患有罗宾序列征(RS)的患者需要复杂的多学科护理。他们可能出现中度至重度上气道梗阻(UAO)。在UAO治疗指征和评估的诊断使用方面存在很大差异。在大多数情况下,RS中UAO的保守管理就足够了。尽管进行了保守管理但UAO仍然持续存在的患者最终需要手术干预。为了确定哪种干预最适合个体RS患者,需要通过诊断测试来确定UAO的程度。• 欧洲各机构在UAO的诊断和治疗选择方面存在很大差异。一个标准化的、国际认可的RS中UAO评估和管理方案可以指导医疗保健专业人员进行评估的时机和指征,以防止UAO的升级。制定这样一个方案可能具有挑战性,因为欧洲国家之间存在很大的财政差异(例如,以国际美元计算的人均购买力平价卫生支出范围从600美元到超过8500美元)。新发现:• 欧洲国家之间客观诊断工具的可及性存在很大差异。与高卫生支出国家(HHECs)相比,低卫生支出国家(LHECs)获得动脉血气分析、二氧化碳分析和多导睡眠图的机会并不相同。这些差异不仅限于可及性;这些诊断工具的质量也存在差异。令人惊讶的是,LHECs和HHECs在获得治疗工具方面没有差异。• 在RS的诊断和治疗工具的可及性方面存在国家异质性,这表明医疗保健的集中化,表明专科护理仅在三级中心提供。通过对RS婴儿的护理集中化,可以以最佳方式优化诊断和治疗,以创建一个统一的欧洲方案,并最终在欧洲实现平等的护理。了解充分监测所需的内容可以导致更好的资源分配,这在资源匮乏的环境中尤为重要。