Smith Shannon M, Stelmar Jenna, Lee Grace, Carroll Peter R, Garcia Maurice M
Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, Division of Urology; Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Cedars-Sinai Transgender Surgery and Health Program; Los Angeles, CA, USA.
J Surg Res (Houst). 2022;5(4):618-625. doi: 10.26502/jsr.10020269. Epub 2022 Dec 9.
It has been demonstrated that patient memory for medical information is often poor and inaccurate. The use of audio recordings for patient consultation has been described; however, to our knowledge this is the first reported use of audio recordings in consultation for gender-affirming surgery. Our aim was to determine whether, and specifically how, audio recording the consultation of patients presenting for genital gender-affirming surgery would be of benefit to patients.
We began to offer all new patients the opportunity to have their consultations recorded. At the end of the consultation the recording was uploaded to a USB, which was given to the patient to keep. We then surveyed all patients who had received a copy of their recorded consultation to query the utility of having access to an audio recording of their consultation.
71/72 (98.6%) patients who were given the option to have their consultation recorded chose to do so. 50/71 (70%) of patients who had their consultation recorded responded to our survey. Patients reported that having access to a voice recording of their consultation was beneficial and was viewed overwhelmingly positively.
Routine audio recording of patient consultations is highly beneficial to patients, with little cost to providers, and should be considered as a valuable addition to the new patient consultation. This approach may have applications in broader clinical contexts where patients face numerous, complex, and nuanced management options. The study would benefit from continued application and a larger (multi-center, international) sample.
已有研究表明,患者对医疗信息的记忆往往很差且不准确。已有文献描述了在患者咨询中使用录音的情况;然而,据我们所知,这是首次报道在性别确认手术咨询中使用录音。我们的目的是确定对接受生殖器性别确认手术的患者咨询进行录音是否以及具体如何对患者有益。
我们开始为所有新患者提供对其咨询进行录音的机会。咨询结束时,录音被上传到一个USB中,并交给患者保存。然后,我们对所有收到咨询录音副本的患者进行了调查,以询问获取咨询录音的效用。
72名有机会对咨询进行录音的患者中有71名(98.6%)选择这样做。71名咨询被录音的患者中有50名(70%)回复了我们的调查。患者报告说,能够获取咨询的语音记录是有益的,并且得到了绝大多数的积极评价。
对患者咨询进行常规录音对患者非常有益,对提供者成本很低,应被视为新患者咨询的一项有价值的补充。这种方法可能在更广泛的临床环境中有应用,在这些环境中患者面临众多、复杂且细微的管理选择。该研究将受益于持续应用和更大(多中心、国际)的样本。