从青少年视角招募和保留参与纵向健康研究:一项定性研究。
Recruitment and retention into longitudinal health research from an adolescent perspective: a qualitative study.
机构信息
UKCRC Centre for Diet and Activity Research (CEDAR) at the MRC Epidemiology Unit, University of Cambridge School of Clinical Medicine, Institute of Metabolic Science, Cambridge Biomedical Campus, Box 285, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
School of Health Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich, United Kingdom.
出版信息
BMC Med Res Methodol. 2023 Jan 16;23(1):16. doi: 10.1186/s12874-022-01802-7.
BACKGROUND
High quality longitudinal studies investigating changes in health behaviours over the transition into early adulthood are critical. However, recruiting and retaining adolescents is challenging. This study explored adolescents' perspectives of signing up to and continuing involvement in a hypothetical longitudinal health research study.
METHODS
Forty-eight individuals (15-20y) participated in nine in-person focus groups about recruitment and retention in research. Participants were (a) school students in the last year of compulsory school (Year 11, 15-16y), (b) school/college students in Sixth Form (Year 13, 17-18y), (c) Further Education students studying after secondary education, but not higher education (16-18y) and (d) young adults not in education, employment, or training (18-20y) across England. Thematic analysis resulted in seven themes.
RESULTS
Driving factors for sign-up included social connection e.g., joining with peer groups, personalised feedback, and incentives, primarily financial. Key barriers were lack of interest, the perception of commitment, and timing of recruitment. Young people preferred recruitment processes via social media with messages tailored to their motivations, monthly data collection of maximally 20-30 min, and hybrid data collection with some in-person contact with a consistent, non-judgemental researcher. The provision of autonomy, choice, and financial incentives were perceived to promote retention.
CONCLUSIONS
Adolescent recruitment and retention strategies need to align with contemporary interests and motivations. Studies should involve adolescents early to develop a planned, systematic approach to participant sign-up and follow-up. Effective and ineffective recruitment and retention strategies should be reported as part of study findings. Future research should trial how perceived barriers to study engagement can be overcome.
背景
高质量的纵向研究调查了青少年向成年早期过渡期间健康行为的变化,这一点至关重要。然而,招募和留住青少年是具有挑战性的。本研究探讨了青少年对参与假设性纵向健康研究的看法,包括报名和继续参与的看法。
方法
48 名参与者(15-20 岁)参加了 9 次关于招募和保留的现场焦点小组讨论。参与者包括(a)学校的最后一年的学生(11 年级,15-16 岁),(b)中学/大学的学生在六年级(13 年级,17-18 岁),(c)继续教育学生在中学教育后接受教育,但不接受高等教育(16-18 岁),(d)18-20 岁未接受教育、就业或培训的年轻人。主题分析产生了 7 个主题。
结果
报名的驱动因素包括社会联系,例如与同龄群体一起加入、个性化反馈和激励措施,主要是经济激励。主要障碍是缺乏兴趣、对承诺的看法以及招募时间。年轻人更喜欢通过社交媒体进行招募,信息针对他们的动机量身定制,每月最多 20-30 分钟的数据分析,以及混合数据收集,有一些与一致的、非评判性的研究人员进行面对面的接触。提供自主权、选择和经济激励被认为可以促进保留率。
结论
青少年的招募和保留策略需要与当代的兴趣和动机保持一致。研究应该尽早让青少年参与,制定计划,系统地处理参与者的报名和后续问题。应该将有效和无效的招募和保留策略作为研究结果的一部分进行报告。未来的研究应该尝试解决参与研究的障碍。